Skip to main content



The 9th Judgment

SARAH WELLS STOOD on the roof of the carport and snaked her
gloved hand through the hole she'd cut in the glass. Her pulse was
thudding in her ears as she unlocked the double-hung window, opened
the sash, and slid quietly into the darkened room. once inside, she
flattened herself against the wall and listened.

Voices rose from the floor below, and she heard the clanking of
silverware against china. Good timing, Sarah thought. in fact,

But timing and execution were two different things entirely.

She switched on her miner's headlamp and took a 180degree
illuminated tour of the bedroom. She noted the console table to her
left, which was loaded with whatnots. She had to watch out for that
table and the scatter rugs on the slick hardwood floors.

The lithe young woman quickly crossed the space, shut the door
between the bedroom and hallway, and headed to the open closet,
which smelled faintly of perfume. Leaving the door open just a
crack, Sarah played her light over racks of clothing. She parted a
curtain of long, beaded gowns, and there it was: a safe in the
closet wall.

Sarah had bet on this. if Casey Dowling was like most
socialites, she dressed for her dinner parties and wore her jewels.
Chances were that she'd left her safe unlocked so she could put her
jewels away later without having to punch in the combination again.
Sarah tugged lightly on the safe's handle --- and the heavy door
swung open.

It was a go.

But she had to work fast. Three minutes, no more.

Sarah's headlamp lit up the contents of the safe while leaving
her hands free to frisk the jumble of satin envelopes and
silk-covered boxes. Way in the back was a brocaded box the size of
a small loaf of bread. She undid the latch and lifted the lid on
the mother lode.

Sarah gasped.

She'd read stories about Casey Dowling for two months and seen
dozens of photos of her at society events, glittering with jewels.
But she hadn't expected the sheer weight of diamonds and precious
stones, the gleaming mounds of baroque pearls.

It was cra-zzzy. Casey Dowling owned all of this.

Well, not for long.

Sarah plucked bracelets and earrings and rings out of the box
and stowed them in one of her two small duffel bags, the straps of
which crisscrossed her chest. She paused to study a particular ring
in its own leather case, to marvel at the frickin' wonder of it ---
when lights flashed on in the bedroom only yards from where she
stood in the closet.

Sarah snapped off her light and dropped to a crouch, her heart
rate shooting into overdrive as she heard the living, booming voice
of Marcus Dowling, superstar actor of theater and the silver
screen, bickering with his wife as he came into the room.

Sarah tucked all five feet eight of herself into a ball behind
gowns and garment bags.

God, she was stupid.

While she'd been ogling the jewels, the Dowlings' dinner party
had ended, and now she was going to get caught and be imprisoned
for grand larceny. Her. A high school english teacher. it would be
a scandal --- and that was the least of it.

Sweat broke out under Sarah's knit cap. Drops of it rolled from
her underarms down the sides of her black turtleneck as she waited
for the Dowlings to switch on the closet light and find her
squatting there, a thief in the night.

CASEY DOWLING WAS trying to squeeze an admission from her
husband, but Marcus wasn't having it.

"What the hell, Casey?" he snapped. "I wasn't staring at
Sheila's boobs, for Christ's sake. every single time we get
together with people, you complain that I'm leering, and frankly,
sweetheart, I find your paranoia very unattractive."

"Ohhhh no, Marcus. you? Leer at another woman? I'm soooo ashamed
of myself for even having had the thought." Casey had a lovely
laugh, even when it was colored with sarcasm.

"Silly cow," Marcus Dowling muttered.

Sarah imagined his handsome face, the thick gray hair falling
across his brow as he scowled. She imagined Casey, too --- her
willowy shape, her white-blond hair falling in a silvery sheet to
her shoulder blades.

Casey cooed, "There, there. I've hurt your feelings."

"Forget it, love. I'm not in the mood now."

"Oh. Sorry. My mistake."

Sarah felt the rebuff as if it had happened to her. Then Marcus
said, "Oh, for pity's sake. Don't cry. Come here."

The room went quiet for a few minutes, until Sarah heard a
whoosh of bodies falling into plumped bedding, then murmuring ---
words she couldn't make out. Then the headboard began to tap
against the wall, and Sarah thought, oh dear God, they're doing

images came to her of Marcus Dowling in Susan and James with
Jennifer Lowe and in redboy with kimberly kerry. She thought of
Casey in Marcus's arms, her long legs wrapped around him. The
tapping became more rhythmic and the moaning became louder and then
there was a long, groaning exhalation from Marcus, and then ---
mercifully --- it was over.

Someone used the bathroom after that, and finally the room went

Sarah squatted quietly behind the curtain of gowns for at least
twenty minutes, and when the breathing outside the closet settled
into sputters and snores, she opened the door and crawled to the

She was almost home free --- but not there yet.

Sarah was quick and quiet as she vaulted to the windowsill, but
when one leg followed the other, she hit the side of the console
table --- and it all went wrong.

There was the tinkling of sliding whatnots as the table tipped
and then crashed, sending its load of picture frames and perfume
bottles to the floor.

Holy crap.

Sarah froze, mind and body, as Casey Dowling bolted into a
sitting position and yelled, "Who's there?"

Sarah's stark fear propelled her out the window. She hung on to
the roof of the carport with all the strength in her fingertips,
then released her grip and made the ten-foot drop.

She landed on grass, knees bent, no pain. And as the Dowlings'
bedroom light came on overhead, Sarah ran. She ripped off her
headlamp and stuffed it into one of the duffels as she sprinted
through the upscale San Francisco neighborhood of Nob Hill.

A few minutes later Sarah found her old Saturn where she'd left
it in the parking lot outside a drugstore. She got into the car,
closed the door, and locked it, as if that could keep out her fear.
She started up the engine and released the hand brake, still
panting, trying not to throw up as she drove toward home.

When she hit the straightaway of Pine Street, Sarah pulled off
her cap and gloves, wiped her brow with the back of her hand, and
thought hard about her escape from the Dowlings' bedroom.

She'd left nothing: no tools, no prints, no DNA. No nothing.

For now, at least, she was safe.

Honestly. She didn't know whether to laugh or to cry.

CASEY'S EYES FLEW open in the dark.

Something had crashed. The table by the window! She felt a
breeze on her face. The window was open. They never opened that

Someone was inside the house.

Casey sat up. "Who's there?" She clutched the blankets to her
chin and screamed, "Marc! Someone is in the room."

Her husband groaned, "You're dreaming. Go back to sleep."

"Wake up! Someone is here," she hissed.

Casey fumbled with the table lamp, knocked her glasses onto the
floor, found the switch, and turned on the light. There. The
console table was turned over, everything broken, curtains blowing
in the breeze.

"Do something, Marc. Do something."

Marcus Dowling worked out every day. He could still bench-press
two hundred pounds, and he knew how to use a gun. He told his wife
to be quiet, then opened his nightstand drawer and removed the .44
he kept fully loaded in a soft leather bag. He shucked the sack and
gripped the gun.

Casey grabbed the bedside phone and pressed the numbers 9-1-1
with a shaking hand. She misdialed, then tried again as Marc, still
half drunk, bellowed, "Who's there?" even when he was serious, he
sounded scripted. "Show yourself."

Marcus looked in the bathroom and the hallway, then said,
"There's no one here, Casey. Just what I said."

Casey dropped the phone back into its cradle, shoved at the
bedcovers, and went to the closet for her robe --- and

"What is it now?"

White-faced, naked, Casey turned to her husband and said, "Oh my
God, Marc, my jewelry is gone. The safe is almost empty."

A look came over Marc's face that was hard for Casey to read. it
was as if he'd had an idea, and the idea was catching fire. Did he
know who robbed them?

"Marc? What is it? What are you thinking?"

"Ah, I was thinking, you can't take it with you."

"What kind of bullshit is that? What do you mean?"

Dowling extended his right arm and aimed the gun at a mole
between his wife's breasts. He pulled the trigger. Boom.

"That's what I mean," he said.

Casey Dowling opened her mouth, sucked in air, and exhaled as
she looked down at her chest, at the blood pumping and bubbling out
of the wound. She clasped her hands to her chest. She looked at her
husband and gasped, "Help me."

He shot her again.

Then her knees buckled and she went down.

PETER GORDON FOLLOWED the young mom out of Macy's and into the
street outside the Stonestown Galleria. Mom was about thirty, her
brown hair in a messy ponytail, wearing a lot of red: not just
shorts but red sneakers and a red purse. Shopping bags hung from
the handles of her baby's stroller.

Pete was behind the woman when she crossed Winston Drive, still
almost on her heels as she entered the parking garage, talking to
the infant as if he could understand her, asking him if he
remembered where Mommy parked the car and what Daddy was making for
dinner, chattering away, the whole running baby-talk commentary
like a fuse lit by the woman's mouth, terminating at the charge
inside Petey's brain.

But Petey stayed focused on his target. He listened and watched,
kept his head down, hands in his pockets, and saw the woman unlock
the hatch of her rAV4 and jam her shopping bags inside. He was only
yards away from her when she hoisted the baby out of the stroller
and folded the carriage into the back, too.

The woman was strapping the boy into the car seat when Pete
started toward her.

"Ma'am? Can you help me out, please?"

The woman drew her brows together. What do you want? was written
all over her face as she saw him. She got into the front seat now,
keys in hand.

"Yes?" she said.

Pete Gordon knew that he looked healthy and clean and wide-eyed
and trustworthy. His all-American good looks were an asset, but he
wasn't vain. No more than a Venus flytrap was vain.

"I've got a flat," Pete said, throwing up his hands. "I really
hate to ask, but could I use your cell phone to call Triple-A?"

He flashed a smile and got the dimples going, and at last she
smiled, too, and said, "I do that --- forget to charge the darned

She dug into her purse, then looked up with the cell phone in
hand. Her smile wavered as she read Pete's new expression, no
longer eager to please but hard and determined.

She dropped her eyes to the gun he was holding --- thinking that
somehow she'd gotten it wrong --- looked back into his face, and
saw the chill in his dark eyes.

She jerked away from him, dropping her keys and her phone into
the foot well. She climbed halfway into the backseat.

"Oh my God," she said. "Don't --- do anything. I've got cash

Pete fired, the round whizzing through the suppressor, hitting
the woman in the neck. She grabbed at the wound, blood spouting
through her fingers.

"My baby," she gasped.

"Don't worry. He won't feel anything. I promise," Pete Gordon

He shot the woman again, poof, this time in the side of her
chest, then opened the back door and looked at the bawler, nodding
off, mouth sticky with cotton candy, blue veins tracing a road map
across his temple.

A CAR SCREAMED down the ramp and squealed around the corner,
speeding past Pete as he turned his face toward the concrete center
island. He was sure he hadn't been seen, and anyway he'd done
everything right. Strictly by the book.

The woman's open bag was lying inside the car. With his hand in
his jacket pocket, using it as a kind of glove, he dug around in
her junk, looking for her lipstick.

He found it, then swiveled up the bright-red tube.

He waited as a couple of gabby women in an escalade drove up the
ramp looking for a spot, then he took the lipstick tube between his
thumb and forefinger and considered what he would write on the

He thought of writing For Kenny but changed his mind. He laughed
to himself as he also considered and rejected PETEY WAS HERE.

Then he got real.

He printed WCF in bold red letters, four inches high, and
underscored the writing with a smeary red line. Then he closed the
lipstick and dropped it into his pocket, where it clicked against
his gun.

Satisfied, he backed out of the car, shut the doors, wiped down
the handles with the soft flannel lining of his baseball jacket,
and walked to the elevator bank. He stood aside as the door opened
and an old man wheeled his wife out onto the main floor of the
garage. He kept his head down, avoiding eye contact with the old
couple, and they ignored him.

That was good, but he wished he could tell them.

It was for Kenny. And it was by the book.

Pete Gordon got into the elevator and rode it up to the third
floor, thinking he was having a really good day, the first good one
in about a year. it had been a long time coming, but he'd finally
launched his master plan.

He was exhilarated, because he was absolutely sure it would

WCF, people. WCF.

PETE GORDON DROVE down the looping ramp of the garage. He passed
the dead woman's car on the ground floor but didn't even brake,
confident that there was no blood outside the car, nothing to show
that he'd been there.

With the garage as packed as it was, it could be hours before
the mom and her bawler were found in that tidy spot near the end of
the row.

Pete took it nice and slow, easing the car out of the garage and
accelerating onto Winston, heading toward 19th Avenue. He reviewed
the shooting in his mind as he waited at the light, thinking about
how easy it had been --- no wasted rounds, nothing forgotten ---
and how crazed it was going to make the cops.

Nothing worse than a motiveless crime, huh, Kenny?

The cops were going to bust their stones on this one, all right,
and by the time they figured it out, he'd be living in another
country and this crime would be one of the cold cases some old
Homicide dick would never solve.

Pete took the long way home, up Sloat Boulevard, up and over
Portola Drive, where he waited for the Muni train to pass with
commuters all in a row, and finally up Clipper Street toward his
crappy apartment in the Mission.

It was almost dinnertime, and his own little bawlers would be
puffing up their cheeks, getting ready to sound the alarm. He had
his key out when he got to the apartment. He opened the lock and
gave the door a kick.

He could smell the baby's diapers from the doorway, the little
stinker standing in the kiddie cage in the middle of the floor,
hanging on to the handrail, crying out as soon as he saw his

"Daddy!" Sherry called. "He needs to be changed."

"Goody," Peter Gordon said. "Shut up, stink bomb," he told the
boy. "I'll get to you in a minute." He took the remote control from
his daughter's hand, switched from the cartoons, and checked the

The stock market was down. oil prices were up. He watched the
latest Hollywood update. Nothing was said about two bodies found in
the Stonestown Galleria parking lot.

"I'm hungry," Sherry said.

"Well, which is it first? Dinner or poop?"

"Poop first," she said.

"All right, then."

Pete Gordon picked up the baby, as dear to him as a sack of
cement, not even sure the little shit was his, although even if he
was, he still didn't care. He put the baby on its back on the
changing table and went through the ritual, holding the kiddo by
the ankles, wiping him down, dusting his butt with powder, wrapping
him up in Pampers, then putting him back in the kiddie cage.

"Franks and beans?" he asked his daughter.

"My absolute favorite," Sherry said, putting a pigtail in her

"Put a shirt on the stink bomb," Pete Gordon said, "so your
mother doesn't have a gas attack when she gets home."

Gordon microwaved some formula for the stink bomb and opened the
canned franks and beans. He turned on the undercabinet TV and the
stove, what wifey should be doing instead of him, the bitch, and
dumped the contents of the can into a pot.

The beans were burning when the breaking news came on.

Huh. Look at that, Pete thought.

Some dork from ABC was holding a microphone, standing in front
of Borders. College kids mugged behind him as he said, "We have
learned that there has been a shooting at the Stonestown garage.
Sources report a gruesome double homicide that you will not
believe. We'll keep you posted as details are released. Back to
you, Yolanda."

YUKI CASTELLANO STEPPED out of her office and called down the
line of cubicles to Nicky Gaines, "You ready, Wonder Boy? or do you
want to meet me downstairs?"

"I'm coming," Gaines said. "Who said I wasn't coming?"

"How do I look?" she asked him, already moving toward the
elevator that would take them from the DA's office to the

"You look fierce, Batwoman. Miss Hot Multicultural USA."

"Shut up." She laughed at her protégé. "Just be ready
to prompt me if I blank, God forbid."

"You're not going to blank. you're going to send Jo-Jo to the
big house."

"Ya think?"

"I know. Don't you?"

"Uh-huh. I just have to make sure the jury knows it, too."

Nicky stabbed the elevator button, and Yuki went back to her
thoughts. in about twenty minutes, she was going to make her
closing argument in the state's case against Adam "Jo-Jo"

Since she'd been with the DA's office, she'd taken on more than
a few crappy cases that the DA was determined to try: she'd work
eighteen-hour days, earning "atta girls" from her boss, Leonard
"red Dog" Parisi, and score points with the jury, all of which
would give her high expectations.

And then she'd lose.

Yuki was becoming famous for losing --- and that stank because
she was a fighter and a winner. And she just frickin' hated to
lose. But she never thought she'd lose --- and this time was no

Her case was solid. She'd laid it out like a hand of solitaire.
The jury had an easy job. The defendant wasn't just guilty, he was
guilty as sin.

Nicky held open the studded leather door to the courtroom, and
Yuki walked smartly down the center aisle of the oak-paneled
chamber. She noticed that the gallery was filling up with
spectators, mostly press and law students. And as she approached
the prosecution table, she saw that Jo-Jo Johnson and his attorney,
Jeff Asher, were in their seats.

The stage was set.

She nodded to her opponent and noted the defendant's appearance.
Jo-Jo's hair was combed and he was wearing a nice suit, but he
looked dazed as only a mope who'd fried his brain on drugs could
look. She hoped that very soon he would look worse, once she nailed
him on manslaughter in the first degree.

"Jo-Jo looks like he's been smoking ganja," Nicky murmured to
Yuki as he pulled out her chair.

"Or else he believes his lawyer's bull," Yuki said loud enough
for her opponent to hear. "Jo-Jo may think he's going to walk, but
he'll be busing it to Pelican Bay."

Asher looked at her and smirked, showing Yuki with his body
language that he thought he was going to whip her.

It was an act.

Yuki hadn't gone up against Asher before, but after less than a
year in the public defender's office, Asher had gotten a reputation
as a "bomb" --- a killer attorney who blew up the prosecution's
case and got his client off. Asher was formidable because he had it
all: charisma, boyish good looks, and a Harvard Law degree. And he
had his father, a top-notch litigator who was coaching his son from
the sidelines.

But none of that mattered today.

The evidence, the witnesses, and the confession were all on her
side. Jo-Jo Johnson was hers.

JUDGE STEVEN RABINOWITZ took a last look at the pictures of his
new condo in Aspen, then turned off his iPhone, cracked his
knuckles, and said, "Are the People ready, Ms. Castellano?"

"We are, your Honor," said Yuki.

She stood, her glossy black hair with the new silver streak in
front falling forward as she straightened the hem of her suit
jacket. Then she stepped quickly to the lectern in the center of
the well.

She turned her eyes toward the jury box and gave the jurors a
smile. A couple of them smiled back, but for the most part they
were expressionless. She couldn't read them at all.

But that was okay.

She just had to give the greatest closing of her life, as if the
dead scumbag victim were the best and brightest of men, and as if
this were the last case she would ever try.

"Ladies and Gentlemen," she said, "Dr. Lincoln Harris is dead
because this man, Adam J. Johnson, knew Dr. Harris was in mortal
danger and let him die with willful disregard for his life. in
California, that's manslaughter in the first degree.

"We know what happened on the night of March fourteenth because,
after waiving his right to remain silent, after waiving his right
to counsel, Mr. Johnson told the police how and why he let Dr.
Harris expire when he could have easily saved his life."

Yuki let her words resonate in the chamber, shuffling her cards
on the lectern before continuing her closing argument.

"On the evening in question, the defendant, who had been
employed by Dr. Harris as a handyman, went out to get cocaine for
the doctor and himself.

"He returned within the hour, and the defendant and the
plaintiff ingested this cocaine. Shortly after that, Dr. Harris
OD'd. How do we know that?

"The defendant told the police --- and it was borne out by
medical experts --- that it was clear Dr. Harris was in extremis.
He was foaming at the mouth and eventually lost consciousness. But,
rather than call an ambulance, the defendant used this opportunity
to remove a thousand dollars and an ATM card from Dr. Harris's

"Mr. Johnson then used Dr. Harris's ATM card, took another
thousand dollars, and bought himself a new leather jacket and a
pair of boots at rochester Big & Tall.

"After that," Yuki told them, "the defendant bought more cocaine
and hired a prostitute, Elizabeth Wu, whom he brought back to Dr.
Harris's home.

"Over the next several hours, Ms. Wu and Mr. Johnson snorted
coke, had sex a few times, and at one point, according to Mr.
Johnson's statement, discussed how to dispose of Dr. Harris's body
once he died. That, Ladies and Gentlemen, shows 'consciousness of

"Adam Johnson absolutely knew that the doctor was dying. But he
didn't call for help for fifteen hours," Yuki said, slapping the
lectern. "Fifteen hours. Finally, at the behest of Ms. Wu, Mr.
Johnson finally called nine one one, but it was too little, too
late. Dr. Harris died in the ambulance en route to the

"Now, we all know that the defense has no defense.

"When facts are against them, defense lawyers resort to
theatrics and to blaming the victim.

"Mr. Asher has told you that Dr. Harris lost his license to
practice medicine because he used drugs. And that he cheated on his
wife. That's true, and so what? The victim wasn't a saint, but even
imperfect people have a right to humane treatment. And they have a
right to justice.

"The defense has portrayed Adam Johnson as a hapless gofer who
didn't know an oD from a CD.

"That's fiction. Adam Johnson knew what he was doing. He's
admitted to all of it: the willful disregard as well as the fun he
had that night, stealing and shopping and snorting coke and having
sex while Dr. Harris lay dying.

"That's why there can be only one verdict. The People ask you to
find Adam Johnson guilty on three counts: of grand larceny, of
intent to deal narcotics, and of reckless disregard for the life of
a human being --- that is, manslaughter in the first degree."

Excerpted from THE 9th JUDGMENT © Copyright 2010 by James
Patterson and Maxine Paetro. Reprinted with permission by Little,
Brown and Company. All rights reserved.

The 9th Judgment
by by James Patterson and Maxine Paetro

  • Genres: Fiction, Thriller
  • hardcover: 368 pages
  • Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
  • ISBN-10: 0316036277
  • ISBN-13: 9780316036276