Skip to main content

Bark Humbug: An Andy Carpenter Mystery

Review

Bark Humbug: An Andy Carpenter Mystery

BARK HUMBUG, David Rosenfelt's 34th Andy Carpenter mystery, is every bit as entertaining, suspenseful and funny as each of the preceding installments. In other words, readers are virtually guaranteed a fabulous time. But there's more good news. In my carefully considered opinion, it offers even more beautiful features than the earlier entries --- funnier funny stuff, more suspenseful suspense, and some effective new techniques that add to our enjoyment of every page.

There are, for example, some “in-jokes” that actually made me laugh out loud. Included are Andy Carpenter's spicy opinions about his wife Laurie's favorite author, David Rosenfelt. You can't get more “inside” than that! There also are some subtle political references that jump off the pages. Consider the personality of the murder victim in the first chapter, Paterson, New Jersey Mayor Craig Henley. He’s hoping to become governor of New Jersey, but he never will fulfill that ambition. He and one of his large donors are shot and killed just outside the site of a town hall meeting during which the mayor had discussed some of his controversial beliefs and proposals. Henley’s character and career reveal fascinating parallels to a certain real-life New York politician who eventually “suffered” the unfortunate event of hair dye running down his face in the middle of a speech. 

Both Henley and that politician were prosecutors who had won big-time guilty verdicts and therefore became heroes in their cities. Both ran for mayor, and both won. Both ultimately were considered tough and unforgiving, rather extreme examples of ultra-conservative disrespect toward the unfortunates in American society. And both were accused of failing to give credit to those who worked effectively to earn those guilty verdicts that made the politicians famous and admired. Finally, both met unfortunate fates themselves. The real-life one was disbarred and had to withdraw from public service. The fictional one was assassinated.

"In my carefully considered opinion, [BARK HUMBUG] offers even more beautiful features than the earlier entries --- funnier funny stuff, more suspenseful suspense, and some effective new techniques that add to our enjoyment of every page."

Still another new Rosenfelt technique is the practice of making disparaging but indirect criticisms of two very important occupations. Andy delivers a clever remark when responding to the troubles of folks with problems, which amounts to, “Well, it's better than being a criminal defense lawyer.” And he doubles down on that self-critical lack of occupational wisdom when he says later, “Well, it's better than being a mystery writer.” Here is typical but always effective Rosenfelt humor, but it’s a particular type that hasn’t been utilized often in previous Andy Carpenter novels.

Now to the unwinding of the plot. First up is the assassination of Mayor Henley and one of his campaign donors, Steven Tiller. A bit later, we learn that the main suspect is a young man named Jon Lowery, a former employee in Henley's office. Jon has a master's degree in computer science. His wife had been murdered by a drug addict, after which he wanted to change the direction of his life. So he joined the Marines and became a member of the Special Forces. He developed PTSD, and after leaving the corps, he found a job as an IT manager at Henley's office. Jon's mission in life was to help drug addicts, and he learned pretty quickly that the mayor's attitude toward them was in sharp contrast to his own. It seemed that the mayor wanted to use the issue as a campaign strategy. Addicts needed to help themselves, and the government had to stay away from their problems.

So Jon went to the town hall in an ugly mood and angrily confronted and threatened the mayor. Then he left. He immediately became the prime suspect in the murders, and the accusation was exacerbated when it was learned that he had extensive training as a marksman, had become an expert at the skill, and looked more and more like the culprit. Then the prosecution became even more certain of his guilt when investigators discovered that the rifle used in the murders was the same model as one that Jon owned.

So Andy --- unwillingly, of course --- takes on Jon as a client. As usual, Andy's case seems impossible to win; Jon looks as guilty as sin. Also as usual, Andy and his team get into all kinds of trouble with very dangerous mafia-type individuals and organizations and willingly place their own lives in desperate situations on Jon's behalf. It's often true in Andy's adventures that it's impossible to prove that the defendant is innocent. The defense only must convince the jury that there is reasonable doubt that the accused is the murderer. So that is Andy's mission. He displays his brilliance during Jon's trial, but when the jury is sent to debate and decide the verdict, the process and the waiting are nerve-racking and extremely anxiety-inducing. But the post-trial events and revelations involve twists that we could not have expected and make BARK HUMBUG even more compelling than some earlier entries in the series.

Reviewing Andy's team's investigative practices and techniques demonstrates once again that the humor and suspense created by Rosenfelt's unique talents are only part of the whole picture. If we very carefully observe each of these novels, we become increasingly aware that our personal identification with the characters and situations are powerful elements of our attraction to the stories.

We easily can relate to each character's flaws and behaviors:

  • Andy's self-deprecating comments as we see that his admitted shortcomings are often our own as well.
     
  • Andy's secretary's hilarious laziness and excuses, which are very much like ours when we simply don't feel like doing something we know darn well we should be doing.
     
  • Andy's dependence on his team and his own weaknesses, reflecting our need to admit that in our most difficult times, we'd better get help from our friends.
     
  • The realization that our most important decisions are so often filled with ambiguity, ambivalence and contradictions that bedevil us, like Andy's admission that he somehow both loves and hates his chosen profession.
     
  • Our realization that so often the ends justify the means, even if we know down deep that the means involve dishonesty and lies. Think of Andy's expert hacker, Sam, when they know that Sam's hacking is flagrantly illegal, or when Andy convinces an unwilling interviewee that he could drag him to court when that is, in fact, impossible.
     
  • And the wish that I could be as quick, cutting and funny as Andy and his friends when they're engaging in their mutually insulting repartee.

All of those factors taken together demonstrate conclusively why Andy Carpenter fans always await the next Rosenfelt/Carpenter combination so happily and consistently. Rosenfelt gives us a magical formula of suspense, humor and even self-realization. I can't wait for the next one.

Reviewed by Jack Kramer on October 16, 2026

Bark Humbug: An Andy Carpenter Mystery
by David Rosenfelt

  • Publication Date: October 13, 2026
  • Genres: Fiction, Mystery
  • Hardcover: 320 pages
  • Publisher: Minotaur Books
  • ISBN-10: 1250427835
  • ISBN-13: 9781250427830