Skip to main content

Reading Group Guide

Discussion Questions

The New Yorkers

1. How does the novel’s neighborhood compare to your community? Does it remind you of any other fictional “villages”?

2. The novel’s title emphasizes the setting. In what way is it essential for these events to take place in New York? What makes the world of dog owners special among other populations inhabiting the city?

3. How were you affected by the various shifts in point of view? What does this cast of characters have in common, and in what ways do they each represent a unique aspect of communities in general?

4. How do you picture the novel’s narrator, whose distinctive storytelling voice provides an air of authenticity throughout? Which twists in these intricate storylines surprised you the most?

5. Discuss the many forms of unrequited love described in The New Yorkers. How do the characters react when their feelings of attraction aren’t mutual, such as the attraction Jody initially has for Everett, or Simon for Jody, or Everett for Polly, or Polly for Chris?

6. What humans were you reminded of while reading about the various personalities of the dogs in The New Yorkers?

7. How did your perception of Jody shift throughout the novel? To what degree is Beatrice responsible for her transformation? In your opinion, who (human or canine) is the novel’s main character?

8. Does Doris really hate dogs, or is her obsession simply a mask for some other, deeper frustration? What brings about her change of heart with Fredericka?

9. What makes George the ideal dog trainer? Do any of his techniques apply to life overall? Why is it so difficult for him to find his purpose before he begins seeing Alexandra?

10. Everett eventually becomes intensely attached to Howdy. Is dog love very different from the other kinds of love he has experienced? Why is he so resistant to pets at first? Do his feelings about his daughter and ex-wife change because of Howdy, or because of Polly?

11. If you were Jody, would you have married Simon? Does he lose interest because of Jody’s hesitation, or would he have lost interest anyway after they were married, due to his self-proclaimed affinity for the single life?

12. Is there any contradiction between Simon’s enthusiasm for hunting and the other characters’ enthusiasm for their pets?

13. Is Jaime the most well-adjusted character in The New Yorkers? What enables him to create a sort of paradise for his numerous children and for everyone who visits his restaurant (except Doris), spending “his whole life in the pursuit of other people’s happiness” (chapter twenty-three)?

14. How might the novel have unfolded if it had been written from Beatrice’s and Howdy’s points of view? What do they think of their neighborhood’s human drama?

The New Yorkers
by Cathleen Schine

  • Publication Date: May 1, 2007
  • Hardcover: 304 pages
  • Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
  • ISBN-10: 0374221839
  • ISBN-13: 9780374221836