Review
The Garden of Last Days
THE
GARDEN OF LAST DAYS is one novel that gives the lie to the notion
that character-driven literary fiction can’t be hitched to a
propulsive plot. Richly imagined and profoundly atmospheric, it
carves out a slice from the netherworld of modern American life
that’s both stark and compassionate.
Set on Florida’s Gulf Coast, much of the novel's action takes
place in the seedy Puma Club for Men, where a dancer and single
mother by the name of April has brought her three-year-old daughter
Franny one evening in early September 2001. Jean Hanson, an elderly
Midwestern widow who is April’s landlord and the
child’s babysitter, is ill and April can’t afford to
sacrifice the several hundred dollars in cash she’ll earn
dancing on this night. Instead, she deposits Franny, her pajamas
and a stack of Disney videos with Tina, the club’s ironically
titled “house mom,” who is responsible for supervising
the dancers. Not surprisingly, Tina’s care is less than
attentive, and when the child wanders outside, she encounters AJ
Carey, a patron who has been ejected for touching one of the
dancers, both his spirit and his wrist broken in the process.
AJ is one of several tormented characters in a novel that is
redolent of the apocalypse, as its title implies. Barred from his
own house by a court order after he strikes his wife, he aches to
be with his own young son. Of all the novel’s characters,
he’s the one with the most compelling vision of an idealized
life, one he’s utterly unequipped to attain. In the parking
lot he sees the abandoned Franny, who becomes a surrogate for his
son, and the impulsive decision he makes kicks the novel’s
plot into high gear.
Throughout the evening, April (or “Spring,” as
she’s known to the patrons of the Puma Club) dances in the
Champagne Room at a cost of $500 an hour for a small, Middle
Eastern young man with a tense demeanor and the “smell of
onions and cigarettes on his breath.” Bassam al-Jizani is a
native of Saudi Arabia and one of the hijackers who is shortly to
depart for Boston to meet his destiny and fundamentally change the
course of American history. Throughout the novel’s first 200
pages, Andre Dubus III brilliantly weaves glimpses of the frank
encounter between Bassam, who calls himself “Mike” ---
utterly contemptuous of the Puma Club’s patrons,
“largely asleep in the evil they do” --- and April, who
tells herself she’ll only remain in that life “till I
didn’t have to anymore.”
Dubus exercises an impressive degree of narrative control to give
the novel its unrelenting pace. Although the entire story is told
from a third person point of view, he offers the perspectives of
eight different characters, skillfully shifting his lens from one
to another to heighten and sustain maximum tension. Over the course
of its 533 pages, these perspectives change constantly, sometimes
in as few as two pages, focusing our vision intensely on the next
dramatic turn in the story’s headlong rush.
As he did in HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG, Dubus excels at creating a
vivid cast of characters driven by powerful and conflicting
desires. On the surface, few of them appear even remotely
sympathetic. We feel like bystanders at a terrible automobile
accident, appalled by the carnage and yet so riveted by the drama
we’re compelled, against our instincts, to watch. But in the
end, as Jean Hanson puts it, “we’re made to look their
fate in the eye squarely and with clarity, devoid of manufactured
hopes and surface lies.”
It would be misleading to suggest that THE GARDEN OF LAST DAYS is a
9/11 novel in the sense of ones like Don DeLillo’s FALLING
MAN or Jonathan Safran Foer’s EXTREMELY LOUD AND INCREDIBLY
CLOSE. The events of that terrible day are discussed only obliquely
in the book’s final pages. Without diminishing them in any
way, Dubus is content to treat them as a faint echo of the turmoil
in the lives of these characters that precede them.
If they had lived, this is the novel that Raymond Carver, or
perhaps Dubus’s father Andre, the brilliant short story
writer and essayist, would have written. We’re fortunate that
it has fallen to the hands of a writer as gifted as Andre Dubus III
to tell this disturbing and yet ultimately redemptive tale.
Reviewed by Harvey Freedenberg (mwn52@aol.com) on April 27, 2011
The Garden of Last Days
- Publication Date: June 1, 2009
- Genres: Fiction
- Paperback: 544 pages
- Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company
- ISBN-10: 0393335305
- ISBN-13: 9780393335309



