The Crimson Portrait
Review
The Crimson Portrait
At
some point in our lives, all of us have found fault with our own
faces. Maybe it was the passing anxiety of youthful acne, freckles,
oddly paired dimples, or stick-out ears. Perhaps it's the lifelong
irritation of inherited imperfections, like a crooked nose, puffy
eyelids, receding chin, sagging jowls, or turkey neck.
Yet, as dissatisfying as we sometimes find ourselves when looking
in the mirror, I can wager a week's worth of coffee breaks that
every last one of us would passionately miss our flawed "ordinary"
faces if suddenly they weren't there anymore.
In THE CRIMSON PORTRAIT, author Jody Shields delves into medical
history from the Great War (1914-1918) to build her remarkable,
often arrestingly beautiful romantic novel around the traumatic
post-combat lives of British soldiers whose faces were horribly
disfigured by explosion wounds.
Amid the emotional, spiritual and physical pain endured by these
sequestered patients (even their families were barred from seeing
them), we meet an exceptional community of medical and physical
caregivers. Thrown together in unexpected assignments at a
commandeered English country house-turned-hospital, they muddle
through their own fears, uncertainties, relationships and
obsessions, along with the estate's owner --- the recent widow of
yet another war casualty --- who is still suffering the initial
throes of grief and denial.
Shields unravels their intersecting stories with a powerful
delicacy one might never expect to find within such a potentially
grotesque theme. She does it so well, in fact, that it is difficult
to tell who the primary players really are.
There is the seemingly tireless surgeon who devotes his entire
short-lived retirement to repairing soldiers' faces; the
dentist-turned-bone sculptor, whose eastern European past remains a
mystery; the deposed "chatelaine" tortured by fleeting glimpses of
her dead young husband; the pragmatic artist whose skill at drawing
surgical procedures competes with her anguished affection for two
lovers; the teenaged draft dodger who yearns to be a surgeon; and
finally, the "model" patient whose poetic good looks were blasted
away forever in a trench across the English Channel. Perhaps the
realization that they are all superbly crafted composite characters
is what adds so much to the strength of this story, which
transcends mere fiction by a quantum leap.
While war has often served to accelerate the development of
surgical "miracles" that have become medical standbys in peacetime,
no other injuries have ever posed challenges as technically
difficult or as heart-rending as those affecting the human
face.
We may be brought up on the truism that appearance is only
superficial and that the "real person" within is most important,
but as recovering soldiers sketched in THE CRIMSON PORTRAIT learn,
nothing will ostracize a human being faster than the sight of his
or her destroyed face. Except for a brief glimpse or two of the
appalled "normal" residents in a nearby rural village, however,
Shields leaves that part of her story prophetically untold.
Read this book and you may well forget you are reading fiction; it
is brilliant, poignant, eloquent and humbling, in all the best ways
fine literature can be.
Reviewed by Pauline Finch on January 7, 2011
The Crimson Portrait
- Publication Date: December 1, 2006
- Genres: Fiction
- Hardcover: 304 pages
- Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
- ISBN-10: 0316785288
- ISBN-13: 9780316785280



