The title INFIDELITY is a little misleading. In truth, the content of the
book can really be summed up as Being Cheated On. Ann Pearlman, ironically a
marriage and family therapist who had her 15 minutes of fame appearing on
"Oprah" to teach married women how to "keep the flame alive," is the voice we
follow throughout this lifetime of coping with the agonizing rejection of
unfaithful men. Not to be too snide --- there is certainly real pain in this
book, and the deep wounds of a philandering father and an unfaithful husband
run deep in Pearlman, sometimes inspiring insightful meditations on the
influence of men on the lives of women. Unfortunately, more often Pearlman
seems to want to beat her readers over the head with how "predetermined" her
husband's affair seems and how unavoidable her own drawn-out and often
melodramatic reaction to it.
Pearlman's experiences with infidelity are not uncommon from the everyday
lives of many people: Her father was a Don Juan who would unabashedly flirt
with waitresses and scantily clad ladies in front of her increasingly
depressed and downtrodden mother. Pearlman spent her formative years
alternately loathing and idolizing her dad, playing out, as she often
indicates, some kind of Freudian archetypal attraction and repulsion with
him. While in college and graduate school, Pearlman swears that she will not
suffer an unfaithful mate but still finds herself playing out that dramatic
pull-and-push with other dangerously attractive and flirtatious men --- men
like her father. Enter Ty, football star, artist, and "poet" (although,
Pearlman renders his speech in Hallmark-like fashion). He is a towering
sexpot of a man, adept at both touchdown receptions and dancing the "mashed
potato." Ty and Ann embark on a 30-year marriage, one that appears incredibly
placid and ideal, even despite the fact that they are an interracial match
and, at first, are unable to conceive children and must adopt.
Obviously, things fall apart fairly late in the game for these two --- a
situation that is doubtless deeply puzzling and shocking for Pearlman. Here
she has been on national television, pitching her tried-and-true method for
maintaining a marriage, and suddenly, Ty begins sneaking off with another
artist who insouciantly flaunts her big diamond stud earrings and wealthy
Japanese husband. It is a startling blow to Pearlman, who assumed she could
control her husband and her marriage by being the dutiful wife, the happy
homemaker, the marriage "expert," while all the while she was somehow in the
grip of forces beyond her control.
Or so she tells it. There can be no doubt that, for the most part, the
infidelity of a partner is something a spouse cannot prevent. Moreover, there
is some truth to the notion that a child who has witnessed her father's
infidelity might have a strong subconscious pull to repeat the same pattern
in choosing a mate who is somehow prone to betray. But here's where
Pearlman's explanation gets weak: her argument rests too much on
"proclivities," hidden tendencies, and inevitabilities. Ty was destined to
cheat on her both because he had a troubled childhood of his own and,
Pearlman avers, because of the very fact that she --- a child of infidelity
--- chose him.
It's all too pat and determined, and crushingly fatalistic. While it is true
that Pearlman was scarred by her childhood, that does not necessarily mean
that she was bound to have those wounds re-opened in adulthood. Moreover, she
has complete control over her own reaction to Ty's infidelity; yet it is
precisely her reaction that evinces her most unexamined and puerile behavior
of all. Instead of trying to protect her own 10-year-old daughter from
hearing of Ty's affair, she openly and sarcastically tells the young girl
that he was doomed to stab them both in the back. Rather than entering into
therapy herself, or giving Ty an ultimatum, Pearlman walks about in a
catatonic state, barely eating, barely taking care of her life and her c
hildren, and still clasping to Ty --- up until he decides to leave for good.
While it is impossible to fault Pearlman her actions --- and heaven knows how
anyone would deal in such circumstances --- it is rather necessary to fault
her presenting this as a sound approach to the ending of a marriage. Pearlman
dwells somewhat self-indulgently over dreams of herself crucified, and the
self-pity carries on far too long. The book, in the end, reaches this
unsatisfying conclusion: "You never know what's going to happen next. A
sudden storm or a glorious sunset." Surely, our own actions do play some part
in shaping our lives; we're not victims of infidelity in the same way that
we're victims of violent rain showers.
Readers of INFIDELITY need not enter into this journey skeptical of
Pearlman's tale; they should merely be aware that this is merely one woman's
faulty journey. Although Pearlman is somewhat of an authority on human
relationships, she is, like all of us, by no means immune to their pitfalls.
--- Reviewed by Meredith Blum