The "quickie" book on some news event or political upheaval that rivets the
nation's attention for a brief season is a durable literary tradition in this
country. As soon as the dust settles --- often before it settles --- the
clicking of word processors is heard in the land, and the lure of instant
profits is practically inhalable.
Such books, however, are seldom memorable. Cobbled together in a hurry and
often composed of prewritten journalistic material, they appear, have their
instant in the sun and are soon rightly forgotten.
Michael Tomasky, a politics-watcher for New York magazine, may have beaten
the odds with his breezy, savvy and colorfully written account of last
November's surreal U. S. Senate campaign in New York, in which former First
Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton overcame a stumbling start to win by a
surprisingly large margin over the young Republican congressman Rick Lazio
for the seat vacated by the Olympian intellectual Daniel Patrick Moynihan.
An "event" it surely was, capturing the whole country's attention second only
to the Gore-Bush battle at the top of the ticket. It had a cast of characters
unparalleled for political deviousness, influence, brassy New Yorkish
assertiveness, and sheer colorfulness. Its 16-month course was marked by a
steady stream of unexpected crises and weird surprises. And at the center of
the storm stood three starkly contrasted people --- Hillary herself, the
first First Lady ever to run for public office; the relatively unknown but
ambitious Lazio; and Rudolph W. Giuliani, New York City's ruthless and
loudmouthed mayor who was Hillary's first opponent until his campaign was
destroyed virtually overnight by a combination of prostate cancer and marital
problems.
The supporting cast was every bit as interesting, both those about whom the
public knew (Bill Clinton, New York Governor George Pataki, Dick Morris, Al
Sharpton) and those who worked in near-total anonymity behind the scenes on
both sides, crafting the ads, plotting the strategy, and massaging the
omnipresent media. Indeed, the New York media, unprecedented in its power and
aggressiveness, is a character in the drama all by itself.
Tomasky writes as a New Yorker for New Yorkers (though he actually hails from
Morgantown, W. Va.!). His book is full of "inside baseball" and the kind of
revealing minutiae that political junkies --- especially New York political
junkies --- love. He handles it all, however, with a deftness and fairness
that is impressive. His book is breezy, bright and slangy, and it works
nicely in conveying the mad and dangerous world of New York state politics.
Sometimes he lets the pace flag while he backs up to fill in background, but
this is a minor complaint in view of his overall achievement.
Another small cavil is Tomasky's failure to recreate the drama of election
night itself, a standard set-piece in books of this sort. Perhaps the need
for quick publication accounts for this odd omission.
One of the book's central themes is Hillary Clinton's need to define herself
in personal terms to New York voters, something she was loathe to do and
never succeeded in doing. For all his attention to this problem, Tomasky does
not succeed in conveying her private essence any more than did anyone else
involved in the drama. Even in victory, she remains an enigma. She wanted to
be seen as issues-oriented, not as a barer of her soul to the public, and
that's how she remained.
But on the twists and turns of the campaign itself, Tomasky is brilliant and
entertaining. Many of these incidents were national news when they happened
--- Lazio charging across the stage to confront Hillary during their first
debate; Hillary courting the malodorous Sharpton; Giuliani's personal
Götterdammerung; Trent Lott's nasty comment after Hillary finally won --- but
Tomasky gives them life with his writing style. His thumbnail
characterizations of the colorful crew of combatants in this battle are
evenhanded and vivid.
You don't have to be a Hillary fan to enjoy this engrossing book (though it
might help, given the outcome). Tomasky has caught a key moment in our
political time and brought it jauntily to life.
--- Reviewed by Robert Finn (Robertfinn@aol.com)