The Talmud is the collected writings that make up Jewish civil law. Every
conceivable ancient issue is supposed to be contained within this holy book:
commerce, marriage, ritual, etc. For millennia, pious Jews have paid for
their religious devotion with their lives. (Rabbi Akiva, one of the most
revered scholars in Jewish lore, was flayed, wrapped in Torah scrolls and
burned at the stake by the Romans because he insisted on teaching young Jews
about their religion.) The tenets within these sacred pages are a constant
source of argument and interpretation. As soon as you think you have the an
swer to one problem, you are off looking for solutions to ancillary
situations.
Sounds remarkably like the Internet, doesn't it? You have come to this
particular site because you want information on books. Maybe something you
see here will trigger a curiosity about other topics, and off you go, looking
for further answers. Rosen's comparisons of the Talmud and the Internet as
sources of information and, to a degree, comfort, are unusual, to say the
least. Both the Web and the Talmud "link" to information, referring the
reader to other data. The sum of all knowledge, theoretically, could be said
to dwell in these two "houses."
The Internet, "like the Talmud, [holds] the promise of a book that is more
than a book," writes Rosen. On the other hand, "unlike the Talmud, [it] has
no moral center. It is a vast, crass, chaotic organism..."
But this book is also about family, a paean and a requiem. Rosen's search for
meaning was brought on by the death of his beloved maternal grandmother (whom
he feels the constant need to differentiate from his father's mother, who
perished during the Holocaust). In seeking solace, he scours the Internet,
finding different sites that open his sensitive eyes and soul to the plight
of his people in general and his family in particular, beginning with a site
devoted to long-destroyed synagogues virtually recreated on-line. The crux of
THE TALMUD AND THE INTERNET is more of the former and less of the latter, but
the mix of spirituality is, nonetheless, most thought provoking.
Rosen, whose work has appeared in The New York Times Magazine, The New York
Times Book Review, The American Scholar, and several anthologies, is also the
author of the acclaimed EVE'S APPLE.
--- Reviewed by Ron Kaplan (ronk23@aol.com)