DECEMBER, 2005 – SEATTLE, WASHINGTON
“I swear to God, I’m going to kill her,” he whispered.
Erin Travino didn’t pay attention to the man seated in the row behind her. She switched on her cell phone, activating the little blue display light. It glowed in the darkened movie theater. Erin punched in the code to check her messages again.
Up on the big screen in front of her, Judi Dench was reprimanding Keira Knightley for something. Erin hadn’t paid much attention to Pride & Prejudice. Maybe she should have been. She had a book report due next week, and hadn’t even chosen the stupid book yet. If she’d been following the movie more closely, she could have pretended to have read Pride & Prejudice. Her English Lit teacher was a sucker for Jane Austen.
Then again, she really didn’t have to try too hard at school lately. Most of her teachers were cutting her some slack. Erin simply had to say she was still traumatized over what had happened last week, and her teachers would grant her an extension or raise her C to a B-minus.
Erin intended to milk the situation for as long as she could. Along with Molly Gerrard, and that nut-job, Warren Tunny, she was prominently featured in all the newspaper articles. The Seattle Post-Intelligencer even ran a photo of her, the halfway-decent snapshot from her high school ID. At least her wavy, shoulder-length, auburn hair was freshly-washed; and the dimpled smile looked natural. Plus she appeared really thin in the picture.
Erin was constantly dieting, even though her friends insisted it was the last thing in the world she needed to do. Tonight, for example, her best friend, Kim, had bought a soda and a large buttered popcorn for the movie. Kim asked if she wanted some popcorn, but Erin just shook her head and sipped her medium Diet Coke. Didn’t Kim know that stuff had the fat equivalent of three Big Macs? At least that was what Erin had heard.
She squinted at the illuminated display on her cell phone: No New Messages.
Someone tapped her on the shoulder, startling her. Erin almost dropped the phone. She glanced over her shoulder.
“Would you mind putting your phone away?” growled the man behind her. He was in his late thirties --- as was the lean, Asian guy with him. “The light is very distracting.”
Erin shifted in her cushioned seat. “Well, I wasn’t talking on it,” she whispered, rolling her eyes.
The man glared at her. The light from the movie screen flickered across his handsome, narrow face. “That’s the fifth time you’ve pulled out your phone and switched it on since the movie started. Do you have ADD or something? How about showing a little courtesy for the people around you, huh?”
Her mouth open, Erin let out a stunned, little laugh.
Suddenly her phone chimed out this ancient tune, I Just Called to Say I Love You, in ring tones. She’d programmed it by accident last week, and couldn’t undo the damn thing.
“Shit,” she muttered. A few people in nearby seats shushed her. The man and his buddy were frowning and shaking their heads.
Flustered, Erin grabbed her purse and retreated up the aisle toward the lobby. Ignoring the filthy looks from several people seated along the aisle, she pressed the Talk button on her phone. “Hello?” she whispered, pushing at the door with her shoulder. She stepped into the narrow, dimly-lit foyer. The door swung shut behind her.
“Hello?” Erin repeated, louder this time.
She heard a click. Frowning, she checked the caller ID: Number Not Listed.
With a sigh, Erin headed into the Harvard Exit Theater’s lobby. They showed mostly foreign and independent films there. Erin got a waft of popcorn smell as she wandered through the large lobby. It had a fireplace, a grand piano, and worn, antique parlor-furnishings that were true to the building’s 1920’s architecture. The concessions stand was in the far corner, and beyond that, a stairway to the restrooms and another theater on the third floor.
Erin paused at the foot of the stairs. She dialed Molly’s number, and got her machine again. Erin clicked off. She’d already left three messages. They’d arranged to meet in front of the movie theater tonight. But Molly had never shown.
Molly was one of the most popular girls in Erin’s class. She was thin and pretty with gorgeous, long, black hair that was right out of a shampoo commercial. Molly wore designer glasses, and somehow managed to look chic --- even in just a sweater and jeans. Molly’s stock only went up after what had happened last week. Erin’s stock soared, too. Suddenly, she mattered.
The day before yesterday, Molly had asked if she wanted to hang out after school. They went to pick up a new pair of glasses for Molly at this store on Capitol Hill. The glasses had square lenses with tortoiseshell frames, slightly nerdy, very funky. Only someone as popular and pretty as Molly could have worn them without looking like a total dork. While in the optical shop with her new friend, Erin wished she had weak eyes --- so she could get glasses like Molly Gerrard. Afterward, they had Diet Cokes and shared a plate of cheese fries at the Broadway Grill. Erin ate only seven fries and was still hungry, but it didn’t matter. She felt so cool, hanging out with Molly.
Kim was an okay friend. But Molly was queen of the “A” crowd, and being friends with her put Erin in the “A” crowd, too. She was devastated Molly hadn’t shown up for the movie tonight. Erin wondered if she’d done something wrong. Maybe Molly didn’t want to hang out with her and Kim. Kim wasn’t “A” list. But no, that wasn’t like Molly; she was nice to everyone.
Erin was still trying to figure out what must have happened when she glanced over toward the lobby and spotted one of the older guys who had been sitting behind her. It was the man’s friend, the slim Asian guy. He seemed to be headed for the concessions stand, but his eyes suddenly locked with hers. He passed by the concessions counter and came toward her.
Erin automatically turned and started up the stairs. She wasn’t afraid of him; she just didn’t feel like hearing another lecture about movie theater etiquette. Halfway up the stairs, Erin figured she could duck into the women’s room and avoid him altogether. But the cell phone slipped out her hand and skipped down a few steps.
The man paused on the landing --- in front of a huge, old poster for An American in Paris. He retrieved her cell phone, climbed the stairs, and plopped the phone in her hand. “Well, I know you couldn’t live without this now, could you?” he muttered.
Her mouth open, Erin didn’t reply. Instead, she just retreated into the women’s room. It was dimly-lit, and slightly creepy.
Erin could hear people laughing in the smaller theater upstairs. Some comedy from Italy was showing.
She caught herself frowning in the bathroom mirror. She flicked back her auburn hair. That guy who had just called her rude would have been asking for her goddamn autograph if he knew who she was. Obviously, he hadn’t seen the newspaper last week. They called her a hero for what she did. A hero.
It had happened last Tuesday in Mr. Gunther’s fifth period study hall. Only about half of the students actually studied or did their homework in study hall; the rest napped, doodled, or tried to pass notes to each other. Gunther, a short, wiry, balding, forty-something wannabe-jock, wouldn’t let anyone talk while he lorded over the classroom. He was a real hard-ass. He sat at the front of class with his nose buried in The Seattle Times sports section.
Erin was at her desk by the windows in the last row, listlessly paging through her US Weekly. Gunther was such a Nazi, he’d assigned seats and wouldn’t let anyone switch. Erin was stuck with a view of the faculty parking lot on one side, and squirrelly Warren Tunny on the other.
Warren sat hunched over his sketchpad. He was always drawing these weird cartoon monsters that looked like a cross between Spongebob Squarepants and Godzilla. Erin never admitted it, but she found his drawings fascinating --- gory, graphic and oddly funny.
Bored, Erin tried to peek at what Warren was drawing. She still couldn’t see the sketch pad. But she noticed something shiny inside Warren’s fatigue jacket. It looked like a gun.
Warren stopped drawing and stared at her.
Quickly, she turned away, and did her best to look bored. With a shaky hand, she flipped through a few pages of her magazine. After a minute, she swallowed hard and stole a glance over at Warren again. He seemed focused on his artwork once more. She could clearly see it now, the gun handle sticking out of his inside coat pocket.
How the hell had he smuggled a gun past the metal detectors?
Biting her lip, she helplessly glanced around the classroom --- at the other students, and at Gunther up in front. None of them had a clue.
She was the only one who knew Warren Tunny had a gun.
Squirming in her chair, Erin wondered if maybe --- just maybe --- the gun was a fake. She tried to catch another glimpse of it. Just then, Warren leaned back, and Erin saw his sketchpad --- and what he’d been drawing.
It was a very creepy, detailed rendition of a smiling skull, with a caption underneath it: THEY WILL BE SORRY. Then, below that, he’d drawn a circle with a strange, titled “V” inside that circle. Below this cryptic image, he’d written in even bigger letters than before, embellished with vines winding around each consonant and vowel: PREPARE TO DIE.
Warren sighed, glanced up at the clock for a moment, and then went back to his drawing.
Erin looked up at the clock, too: 1:05.
She suddenly realized, the tilted “V” inside the circle was supposed to be the hands of a clock. Her mouth open, she watched Warren draw the clock digits around the inside parameter of that circle. 1:10 was the time on the clock in his picture. Just five minutes from now.
Was that when he planned to start shooting?
She could be wrong. Still, she wasn’t about to wait until he pulled his gun out to know for sure. Her heart pounded furiously, and she could hardly breathe. She had to do something. Her cell phone was in her purse. Gunther didn’t allow people to use them during his study hall. And she couldn’t pass anyone a note. Warren was her only neighbor.
Biting her lip, Erin glanced around the classroom again --- at all her classmates, looking so bored, so unaware that within minutes there could be screams and blood and chaos. Erin glanced at the clock on the wall again: 1:07. Hunched forward, she took her spiral notebook out of her purse, opened it, and jotted down a few words. She glanced over her shoulder to make sure Warren couldn’t see what she was writing. Then she tore the piece of paper from the notebook and folded it.
Warren put his pencil down, and flipped over the sketchpad. Erin wasn’t sure why he’d done that. Maybe his work was finished. He probably didn’t want anyone in the class to see it --- not just yet. Perhaps it was for later, for the police to discover. Erin felt a chill race through her.
Grabbing her purse, Erin unsteadily got to her feet. “Mr. Gunther?” she said, hardly able to get the words out. Any minute now, she expected Warren to shoot her in the back. Making her way to the front of the classroom, she approached Gunther’s desk. She tightly clutched her purse against her stomach. “Mr. Gunther?” she repeated.
He barely looked over the top of his newspaper. “Go back to your seat,” he muttered.
Erin cleared her throat. “Mr. Gunther, I need to use the rest room. I have a --- a problem.” She handed him the note she’d just written, then started for the door.
“I said, back to your seat!” he barked. His chair made a scrapping noise on the floor as he pushed himself back from the teacher’s desk. Everyone was looking at them.
Erin retreated for the door. She wasn’t sure she would make it. Her hand fumbled for the knob, then she swung open the door and ducked out to the hallway. She could hear people murmuring, and Gunther’s voice: “All right, enough! I want quiet!”
Erin shut the door behind her. But she still couldn’t get her breath. This wasn’t over yet. It hadn’t even begun.
There was a window in the door --- with thin, crisscrossed wire in it. Erin could see Gunther standing at his desk with her note in his hand. But he hadn’t looked at it yet. He scowled at everyone in the classroom. “I want quiet!” he repeated.
Pulling her cell phone out of her purse, Erin switched it on and dialed 9-1-1. It rang twice. Through the window in the door, she watched Mr. Gunther finally glance down at her note.
She hadn’t much time to write anything. All it said was: “Warren Tunny has a gun in his jacket. I’ll call 9-1-1.”
A click interrupted the third ring tone: “Seattle Police Emergency,” the woman said. “9-1-1 operator.”
For a moment, Erin was speechless. She was watching Gunther’s reaction. Frowning, he set her note on the desk, then glanced in Warren’s direction. “Tunny, stand up!” she heard him bark.
Oh, no, no, no, you stupid son of a bitch, she wanted to scream.
Erin became aware of the 9-1-1 operator on the other end of the line: “Police Emergency. Can I help you?”
While the operator talked, Erin could hear Gunther’s voice, raised in anger. Suddenly a girl in the classroom screamed: “Oh, God, no!” Then there were more screams, and it sounded like someone knocked over a chair.
“Oh, Jesus,” Erin said, louder this time, her voice cracking. “I’m at --- at --- James Madison High School, outside room 207, and this guy’s got a gun...”
Through the window in the door, she could see Gunther shaking his head and raising his hands. He looked terrified. Any minute now, she expected to hear the first shot.
The 9-1-1 operator was telling her to remain calm. The woman wanted to know if anyone had been hurt, and how many gunmen there were.
“It’s just one guy, a student, Warren Tunny. I’m outside the classroom right now, but I can still see them in there. I --- ” Erin fell silent as she caught a glimpse of Warren and Mr. Gunther in the window. Warren pressed the gun barrel to Gunther’s head. The wiry, little hard-ass teacher was cringing and trembling.
“Everyone, just shut up and sit down!” Warren screamed. He shook even worse than Gunther. Warren’s face was so flushed it was almost matched the color of his frizzy red hair. “I mean it, shut the hell up, all of you…”
“Oh, my God,” Erin whispered into the phone, backing away from the door. “I think he’s going to shoot somebody. For Christ’s sakes, please, do something! Send the police here…”
“All right, stay calm and tell me your name,” the operator said.
“Erin --- Erin Travino.”
“Erin, I want you to confirm for me that you’re calling from James Madison High School on Ridgeway Drive, and right now in room 207, one of the students has a gun and he’s threatening people. Is that correct?”
Erin couldn’t answer her. She couldn’t move or speak, because at that very moment, the door to room 207 was opening. Warren Tunny stood at the threshold, gazing at her --- with the gun aimed at her heart.
“Come on back inside, Erin,” Warren whispered.
She gaped at him. Tears welled in Warren’s eyes. He looked scared, but determined.
Erin could hear some girls quietly sobbing in the room. She didn’t know where Gunther had gone, but he wasn’t in the doorway with Warren.
“Put away the phone, and come here,” he whispered.
“Erin? Can you answer me?” the 9-1-1 operator was asking.
With her eyes fixed on the gun in Warren’s trembling hand, Erin obediently clicked off the phone and slipped it into her purse. She shook her head. “Please, Warren, don’t shoot,” she whispered. “Can’t we just talk? You --- you don’t have to do this…”
“Inside,” he said, nodding toward the classroom.
Terrified, Erin edged past him and into the room.
Warren stepped in after her and shut the door. There was something so final about the sound of that door closing and the catch clicking. It made Erin flinch.
She saw Gunther in the far corner of the room, facing the blackboard with his hands behind his head. Shaking, he warily glanced over his shoulder at her and Warren.
From her desk in the middle of the room, one girl cried so hard she started convulsing. The whole desk shook as the mousey, thin, long-haired girl sobbed uncontrollably.
Her neighbor, Molly Gerrard, stood up, grabbed the girl’s hand and steadied her. “Warren, you need to put that gun away,” she said, with a slight tremor in her voice. Most of the guys in the junior class were hot for Molly; Warren was almost certainly among them. “You’re scaring everyone,” Molly said to him. She nervously touched her glasses. “I know you’ve suffered, but you’re better than this --- ”
“Shut up!” he cried.
Erin felt the barrel of the gun poke the back of her head. She gasped.
“No, Warren,” Molly continued, her voice still shaky, but even louder than before. “You need to hear this. You’re so much better than the assholes who have picked on you. You’re not a bully, Warren. You have all the power right now. But you also --- you also have an opportunity to show everyone that you’re --- better than the people who have been mean to you. You’re better than them, Warren. You know you are…”
Grabbing Erin’s auburn hair, Warren snapped her head back. She recoiled and cried out again. Yet at the same time, she realized he was now pointing the gun at Molly. His breathing was even heavier than before, more agitated.
“Listen to her, Warren,” she managed to say. “Molly’s right. You don’t have to do this. You --- you’re a nice guy, and a good artist. Your cartoons, they’re --- brilliant --- ”
His grip loosened on her hair. “I don’t want to hurt anybody,” he muttered.
“I know you don’t,” Molly said. “You’re a good person, Warren. So, please, put the gun down….”
“You’re only making things worse for yourself, Tunny!” Mr. Gunther called out from his corner. With his hands still raised, he glanced over his shoulder toward Warren. “You’re already in a heap of trouble, mister, and I can guarantee --- ”
“Why don’t you just shut up?” Molly retorted. “You’re not helping!”
Someone in the classroom gasped at her remark. Erin glanced back at Warren for a moment. A smile flickered across his splotchy face, and he lowered the gun.
“Warren, don’t listen to him,” Molly continued. “Listen to your heart. You haven’t hurt anyone yet, and I don’t think you will. Everyone in this room --- right now --- realizes that you’ve gotten a raw deal. And I for one am very sorry. I hope you’ll accept my apology…”
Warren said nothing. But Erin felt him let go of her hair. For a moment, no one said anything. Then Erin heard a click. Panicked, she swiveled around and saw it was merely Warren setting the gun down on Mr. Gunther’s desk.
He started to cry.
At that same time, she heard the sirens shrieking in the distance. Warren must have noticed them, too. Tears streaking down his face, he turned toward the window.
All at once, someone in the front row yelled out: “Grab him!”
It happened so quickly, Erin barely saw the two guys charging toward her and Warren. One of them shoved her out of the way, and she slammed into the teacher’s desk. It knocked the wind out of her. Screams filled the classroom --- competing with the sirens’ wail outside. One guy savagely pummeled Warren, who cried out and fell to the floor. The other student started kicking him. It was utter chaos --- with everyone suddenly jumping out of their seats and heading for the door. Desks and chairs were knocked over. All the while, Gunther kept screaming, “Hold him down! Hold the son of a bitch down!” He sprung from his corner and grabbed the gun off his desk.
“Stop it!” Molly yelled. “Stop! You’re hurting him!” She ran up the aisle and tried to pull one of the guys off Warren, but he shoved her away. Molly’s glasses flew off her face and she tumbled into the front row of desks. “My glasses!” Molly cried, just as someone inadvertently stepped on them.
Dazed, and curled up on the floor by Gunther’s desk, Erin tried to catch her breath. The sirens outside were getting louder and louder, almost deafening.
When it was all over, Warren Tunny had two cracked ribs, a fractured arm, broken nose, black eye, and several cuts and bruises. The police took him to Harborview Hospital. In the ambulance, Warren had insisted that he hadn’t intended to kill anyone --- just himself. He’d planned to shoot himself in front of his classmates. He’d figured, maybe then, they’d be sorry for treating him so badly.
Of course, no one believed him. By the end of the day, the same people who made fun of Warren were making jokes about what had almost happened, and they were still referring to him as Pubes.
Warren’s two study hall classmates, after beating him so severely, had figured they would be portrayed as heroes of the day by the local press. But Molly and Erin garnered all the attention and accolades. They’d been the ones who had defused a potential bloodbath. They’d been the ones who had pleaded and reasoned with the gunman. They’d gotten him to surrender, and the media linked them together as heroes.
Maybe that was the only reason Molly had asked Erin to hang out with her after school the day before yesterday. While picking up those cool new glasses with the square tortoiseshell frames, they’d talked about Warren, and the creeps who had been mean to him. Molly had wanted to visit Warren in the hospital, where doctors and police kept him under surveillance. She’d asked Erin to come along with her --- and show Warren she had no hard feelings. “You don’t have to say yes right now,” Molly had told her. “Think about it, and tell me later. I just figure it would mean a lot to Warren if he knew you’d forgiven him, you know?”
Erin hadn’t yet committed to making the hospital visit. The notion of seeing Warren Tunny again and being nice to him --- so soon after he’d held a gun to her head --- kind of freaked her out. At the same time, she didn’t want Molly to think she was a jerk. They’d agreed to talk about it later. It had seemed as if they were becoming very good friends.
So Erin couldn’t understand why Molly blew off their movie date tonight. Hell, Pride and Prejudice had been Molly’s idea.
With a sign, Erin frowned at her reflection in the washroom mirror again. The audience watching the Italian comedy upstairs let out another round of laughter.
Erin’s cell phone rang once more --- that same, stupid, I Just Called to Say I Love You tune. She quickly retrieved the phone from her purse and switched it on. “Yes, hello?”
“Erin?” the woman said edgily. “Is this Erin?” The voice wasn’t familiar.
“Yes. Who’s this?”
“Erin, I’m Hannah Gerrard, Molly’s mother. Is Molly with you --- by any chance? Have you heard from her?”
“No, she’s not, Mrs. Gerrard,” Erin murmured. “She was supposed to meet me and my friend here at the Harvard Exit for a movie about an hour ago, but she didn’t show.”
An older woman with short-cropped silver hair stepped into the restroom. She frowned at Erin, then brushed past her and ducked into one of the two stalls. Erin ignored her.
“Listen, Erin,” Molly’s mother said, a tremor in her voice. “The police found Molly’s car an hour ago --- on that little road behind Lakeview Cemetery. The car had a flat. The driver’s door was open, and the hazard lights were blinking. It --- it just doesn’t make sense. Molly’s got a cell phone, for God’s sakes. Why didn’t she call us for help? We’re only five blocks away…”
Erin knew the road: a narrow strip of pavement that ran a few blocks alongside the sprawling cemetery’s high chain-link fence. There was a park on the other side of the road --- with a smaller, unfenced, old cemetery for Veterans of Foreign Wars. Only a block away, quaint, charming houses bordered the park, but there was still something remote and slightly foreboding about that little back road --- especially at night. Surrounded by so many graves, it was an awfully scary spot to have car problems.
But Erin figured Molly had kept a cool head, the same way she’d had with Warren last week. Molly was a lot braver than her. Still, Mrs. Gerrard was right. It made no sense. Molly’s car was found only five blocks from her home --- and less than a mile from this very movie theater. Why hadn’t she called anyone for help? What had happened to her?
Erin swiveled around and gaped at the woman with the close-cropped silver hair. She still had that same haughty look on her wrinkled face as she emerged from the stall. “The use of cell phones is prohibited in public restrooms,” she announced.
Erin curled her lip at her. “What?”
“You’re not supposed to use cell phones in here!” the woman said loudly. “Why are you an exception? There are cameras on cell phones. It’s prohibited to be using --- ”
Erin started to wave her away.
“I don’t appreciate having my privacy invaded!” the woman declared. “I’d like to take a pee without having it broadcast coast to coast on your stupid cell phone! Why don’t you go talk in the lobby, for God’s sakes? Why do you have to talk in here?”
Erin held the phone against her breast for a moment as she ducked into the other stall. “Christ, lady, get off my case!” She shut the stall door and locked it.
“Rude!” the woman exclaimed, over the sound of the water running in the sink. Then Erin heard the roar of the hand dryer.
“I’m sorry, Mrs. Gerrard,” she whispered. Standing in front of the toilet, Erin had her back pressed against the divider between the two stalls. “There’s this crazy woman here…”
“The police are combing the neighborhood right now,” Mrs. Gerrard explained. “When she left, Molly told me she had to run an errand before the movie. That was at five o’clock, over three hours ago. I keep thinking --- if Molly was meeting someone, maybe this person has an idea where she wandered off to. Does she have a new boyfriend she didn’t tell me about?”
“I --- I don’t think so.”
The hand drier shut itself off, and all Erin heard was the sound of the faucet dripping in the restroom sink. She figured the silver-haired woman had left.
“Will you call me if you hear from Molly?” Mrs. Gerrard asked on the other end of the line.
A shadow suddenly swept across the tiled floor, distracting Erin for a moment. She couldn’t see anyone’s feet in the gap beneath the stall door, but obviously somebody else was there. Was that crazy lady still in the bathroom?
“Erin?” Molly’s mother said.
“Um, of course, I’ll call you the minute I hear from Molly, Mrs. Gerrard,” she said, at last. “I --- I’m sure Molly’s all right. Could you have her call me when she gets in?”
“I will,” Mrs. Gerrard said with a tremor in her voice. “I hope that’s soon. Thank you, honey.”
Erin heard a click on the other end. Someone passed by the stall again. She spotted a shadowy figure --- so briefly --- through the crack in the stall door, where it was hinged. Whoever it was, they hadn’t gone into the other stall or used the sink. So why were they sneaking around in there? She could still hear the faucet dripping, but no footsteps.
Maybe it was the disconcerting news about Molly that unnerved her, or the fact that two people had just chewed her out for using her cell phone. But she had a feeling something was horribly wrong. She’d had that same awful sensation in her gut last week when she’d been sitting next to Warren Tunny in fifth period study hall.
With the phone tightly clutched in her hand, Erin leaned toward the hinged side of the stall door. Something darted past the door again, and Erin gasped.
It was a man. She saw him this time, but she didn’t get a look at his face. He moved too fast --- toward the stall behind her. It looked like he was wearing one of those clear, thin, plastic rain-jackets over his dark clothes.
“Who’s there?” she called out, her voice quivering.
No response --- just the sound of that faucet dripping steadily.
“I know someone’s there!” Erin said loudly. “I’m gonna scream in a minute, I mean it!” She turned and glanced down at the gap under the stall partition and the floor. It didn’t look like he’d ducked in the next cubical. If someone was playing a perverse joke on her, he certainly would have given himself up by now.
But this was no joke.
Trying to catch her breath, Erin focused on the phone in her hand. For the second time in a week, she dialed 9-1-1. She was about to press the send button when something flew over the top of the stall.
Startled, Erin recoiled. The small lightweight object bounced off her shoulder, then landed on the tiled floor --- right by the base of the toilet.
Erin saw what it was, and all at once she couldn’t breathe or move. Paralyzed, she just stared down at the pair of glasses with square tortoiseshell frames.
One of the lenses to Molly’s new glasses was cracked.
“Oh, my God…” Erin whispered. With a shaky hand, she punched the send button on her cell phone.
Suddenly, she felt something sting her just above ankle. Crying out, Erin looked down and saw his rubber-gloved hand reaching beneath the stall partition. She saw the glint of a knife. It slashed at her ankle again. She felt the blade scrape against her bone this time. Blood sprayed across the black and white tiled floor.
Erin screamed. She tried to back away. But like a snake, his gloved hand darted under the partition, and he grabbed her by the ankle. All at once, the cell phone flew out of Erin’s hand and fell into the toilet. Water splashed out of the bowl. Erin struggled to keep her balance, but it was impossible. She slammed against the partition wall, and then tumbled down to the wet, tiled floor. She screamed and kicked. The more she kicked, the more blood spurted from the wounds across her ankle.
But he wouldn’t let go. He was pulling her through the gap under the stall divider, and dragging her across the floor.
Lisa Briscoe noticed the two police cars parked in front of the Gerrards’ white stucco --- three lots down from her own house. She was walking Toby, the family’s miniature German Schnauzer.
With one hand clutching the collar of her winter coat and the other holding Toby’s extendable leash, Lisa passed the Gerrards’ house. She’d heard the Gerrards’ had been hounded by snoops and people driving by the house at all hours. Some of them even snuck across the lawn and tried to peek into the windows. They wanted to look at Molly, the pretty --- and now famous --- 17-year-old who had been on the TV news and in the papers for thwarting a possible massacre at James Madison High School last week. Lisa had heard the Gerrards’ had phoned the police twice last week, because of those obnoxious people skulking around outside their house. Lisa couldn’t believe it was still going on.
Lisa approached her usual stopping point: Interlaken Drive, a dark, winding road through dense woods --- with the occasional, secluded, ridiculously-expensive home. Lisa took Toby only to the edge of Interlaken because those woods were full of possums and raccoons, and she didn’t want Toby chasing after one. He was no match for such creatures. Ages ago, when she was a kid, her dad had told her how he’d once seen a German Shepherd try to tussle with a raccoon --- only to be torn apart in seconds. Lisa had steered clear of raccoons ever since.
There was something else about the dark, lonely, snakelike road that scared her. “Sometimes when I’m on this road, I half-expect to find some guy standing there around the next curve,” her husband had said, steering down Interlaken late one night after a party. “I can see the headlights suddenly illuminating this dude in a hockey mask, carrying a meat cleaver. And then, further up the road, there’s this car with a hacked up body in it…”
“Well, gee, thanks for that image, hon,” Lisa had said, squirming in the passenger seat. As a joke, she and her husband often referred to Interlaken as Hockey Mask Lane.
So raccoons and possums weren’t the only reason she rarely took Toby beyond the edge of Interlaken Drive.
But on this December night, Toby still hadn’t pooped yet. Plus it was early; and the cops were parked in front of the Gerrard’s house --- only two blocks away. So Lisa started down Interlaken with Toby. She pulled a small flashlight out of her purse and switched it on. She would give Toby until the first curve in the road, and if he still hadn’t done his business by then, she’d turn around. “C’mon, Toby, this is your last half block,” she muttered, glancing at the darkened woods around her. “Time to shit or get off the pot.”
There was no sidewalk on the road, and the thicket came right up to the curb. A chilly wind rattled the tree limbs. Bushes swayed slightly and dead leaves scattered across the pavement. Toby strained on the leash. He eagerly sniffed at the base of practically every tree and shrub they passed. Suddenly he stopped, raised a paw, and looked deeper into the woods as if he saw something moving in there. He strained at the leash again.
Lisa gazed over in the same direction. Through the trees, she noticed an eerie red glow in the distance --- perhaps around the next curve in the road, or maybe even further. Was it a car with its parking lights on?
Toby was still staring in that direction. His ears moved, and his little body seemed to stiffen.
Lisa shined the flashlight into the woods. The beam cast strange, flickering shadows as Lisa directed it across the trees and shrubs. She couldn’t see anything. “Okay, kiddo,” she said, in a shaky voice. “Here’s where we do a U-turn…” She tugged at the leash, but Toby wouldn’t budge. “C’mon now, there’s nothing out there...”
But there was.
A few yards feet away, deeper into the woods, her flashlight’s beam caught a shrub moving --- as if someone might have just ducking behind it. She heard twigs snapping.
Lisa tugged at the leash again. But Toby was immobile, still staring in that direction. He let out a yelp. Again, Lisa saw something move amid the shadowy trees. She directed the flashlight’s beam past the base of a tree. Close to the forest floor, she saw two eyes staring back at her. They glinted in the light.
“Oh, my God,” Lisa gasped.
The raccoon didn’t seem startled or riled. He merely glanced up from his meal for a moment. Then he went back to gnawing at the bloody slash across the dead girl’s throat. The pale cadaver was clad in just a bra and panties.
Lisa couldn’t move. She watched in horror as the raccoon half-stood on its hind legs, hovering over his feast. Tresses of the girl’s long black hair were caught in the creature’s claws, and her head turned a little when he moved again.
In the flashlight’s beam, Lisa could see her face now.
She recognized the dead girl --- even though Molly Gerrard wasn’t wearing her glasses.
“The person you are calling is not available,” said the recording on the other end of the line. “This call is being forwarded to an automated voice system. Please leave a message for…” Erin’s voice chimed in for two words: “Erin Travino.” Then the recorded generic voice took over again: “…after the tone.”
Standing on the stairway landing of the movie theater’s lobby, Kim held the cell phone to her ear and waited for the beep. On the wall behind her was a huge old poster of Gene Kelly dancing with Leslie Caron in An American in Paris.
She only reached this automated voice system when Erin switched off her cell phone or her battery was dead. And Erin practically never switched off her phone. Erin’s regular message had her own voice with rock music in the background: “Hey, this is Erin, and you know what to do!”
But right now, Kim didn’t know what to do.
She’d been sitting in the theater for the last fifteen minutes with an empty seat beside her and Erin’s coat draped over the armrest. One of the guys behind her had stepped out and come back in the duration; but that had been at least ten minutes ago. Finally, Kim had gotten up and hurried to the lobby. But she hadn’t seen Erin anywhere. So Kim had pulled out her cell phone, dialed Erin’s number and started up the stairs to the women’s rest room.
“Hello, Erin?” she said, holding the phone to her ear as she continued up the stairs. “Where are you? Did you ditch me or something? I can’t believe this. You’ve totally ruined a really good movie for me. You’re not in the lobby, so I’m about to check the restroom. I’m hoping you’re there.” She let out an exasperated sigh. “If not, for God’s sakes, call me, okay?”
Kim clicked off the line as she approached the women’s rest room on the second floor. Pushing open the door, she stopped suddenly. The light was off. As far as she could tell, no one was in there. Past some muffled rapid Italian dialogue from the film showing upstairs, Kim only heard the rhythmic drip of a leaky faucet. She felt along the wall for the light switch.
Her hand brushed against something wet on the wall. Shuddering, she stepped back and gazed at her fingertips. Blood.
He paid for his latte, and then politely asked the barista for the bathroom key.
No one in the Joe Bar Café paid much attention to him. As far as he could tell, none of the other customers in the bistro had seen him emerge from the old, three-story brick building that housed the movie theater across the street.
He found a small table by the window, with a view of the theater entrance and the lighted marquee. Leaving his latte on the table, he asked the bearded twenty-something man with a laptop notebook at the next table to make sure no one took his spot while he was in the washroom.
“Sure, no sweat,” the guy said, barely looking up from his notebook.
He thanked the man, then carried his Nordstrom bag into the bathroom at one side of the barista counter. It was tiny, with a narrow door and barely enough room for the sink and toilet. The walls were painted burnt orange, and the management had posted a reminder above the sink that all employees had to wash their hands after using the facilities. Above that little sign hung a mirror.
He studied his reflection for a moment. His face was clean, and his hair appeared slightly damp. With a sigh, he lowered the toilet seat lid and set down his bag. Then he turned to mirror again. With his hand, he pressed down on the top of his head, mashing the hair against his scalp. Drops of blood slithered down his forehead.
He quickly grabbed a paper towel from the dispenser above the toilet and dabbed up the blood. Then he ran the paper towel over his head, and glanced at the crimson streaks soaked into the fiber sheet.
He should have worn a shower cap when he’d killed her.
Earlier, in the women’s lavatory at the movie theater, he’d quickly rinsed off his face. He’d shucked off the blood-spattered, plastic rain-jacket and gloves. They were now in a dark plastic bag, stuffed inside the Nordstrom tote. He hadn’t much time to clean up in that theater washroom, and the job on Erin had been messy.
Molly Gerrard had been much easier --- and neater --- three hours earlier.
She had been his first kill --- ever. He’d tried to kill before, years ago, but it hadn’t worked out. That failure was still the source of a lot of bitterness and frustration in him.
So he was surprised to have pulled off Molly’s murder without a hitch. He’d been following her around for days now. He knew her car, and had overheard several of her cell phone conversations. So he often knew what Molly was going to do before she did it.
Late this afternoon, he’d skulked up the Gerrards’ driveway, crouched down behind Molly’s Honda, and set a small board with four nails driven through it under the left rear tire. Less than an hour later, she stepped out the house and hurried into the car. It only took four blocks for the tire to deflate --- and in a perfect, remote spot, too.
He pretended he’d just happened by. And Molly looked so glad to see him --- right up until the moment he punched her in the face. With one blow, he bloodied her nose, broke her glasses and knocked her unconscious.
He drove her eight blocks to the ravine-like drive, where she started to regain consciousness. She was dazed and almost docile as he hauled her into the dark, wooded area. But then Molly seemed to realize what was happening. She pleaded with him --- employing, no doubt, the same kind of reasoning and logic she’d used in school last week to save the lives of her classmates. Only it didn’t work this time. It was hard for Molly to rely on those powers of verbal persuasion once he slashed her throat. Instead of words, a strange gurgling sound emitted from her mouth during the last few moments of her life.
He’d gotten only a few drops of blood on his glove and on the sleeve of his clear rain-jacket. He whipped it clean with two Kleenex.
Along with Molly’s broken glasses, he took her cell phone. There were three messages from Erin Travino about the movie: first, saying she’d meet Molly in front of the theater; next, asking Molly what had happened to her; and finally, saying where she and Kim were sitting --- if Molly was still interested in meeting them.
As if Erin hadn’t already made it easy enough for him to find her, she was the one who kept switching on her cell phone and checking her messages during the movie. That little blue light had stood out in the darkened theater. He’d followed her --- and that blue light --- out to the lobby, then up to the women’s bathroom.
He wondered if someone had discovered her body yet. Standing over the small sink in the coffee house washroom, he rinsed Erin’s blood out his hair. He watched the pink water swirl against the white porcelain. With some paper towels, he pat-dried his scalp, then checked for more blood on his jeans and shoes. He’d lucked out, just a few drops on his black sneakers.
After cleaning off the sink, he was about to toss away the used paper towels, but hesitated. They were smeared with blood. He didn’t want anyone in the café later linking him to the murder across the street.
He stuffed the bloodied paper towels into the plastic bag, which was tucked inside his Nordstrom tote. Then he stepped out of the bathroom, returned the key to the barista, and headed back to his table. He set the Nordstrom bag down by his chair.
Sipping his latte, he stared at the theater across the street. He couldn’t help feeling a bit disappointed. Perhaps that was why he took a chance coming here. He would have been better off getting far away from the theater as quickly as possible. But he needed to see peoples’ reactions to what he’d done. From this front row seat, he could see their shock and panic. Maybe then it would feel complete.
Across the street, the theater door flung open. He spotted the young, pretty, black woman who had torn his ticket earlier. With a look of alarm, she paused at the threshold,