Water splashing. A gray mosaic tile tub sunk deep into a
Water pours slowly from an old brass spout, and darkness pours
through a window. On the other side of old, wavy glass is the
piazza, and the fountain, and the night.
She sits quietly in water, and the water is very cold, with melting
ice cubes in it, and there is little in her eyes—nothing much
there anymore. At first, her eyes were like hands reaching out to
him, begging him to save her. Now her eyes are the bruised blue of
dusk. Whatever was in them has almost left. Soon she will
“Here,” he says, handing her a tumbler that was
handblown in Murano and now is filled with vodka.
He is fascinated by parts of her that have never seen the sun. They
are pale like limestone, and he turns the spigot almost off, and
the water is a trickle now, and he watches her rapid breathing and
hears the chattering of her teeth. Her white breasts float beneath
the surface of the water, delicate like white flowers. Her nipples,
hard from the cold, are tight pink buds. Then he thinks of
Of chewing off nubby pink erasers when he was in school, and
telling his father and sometimes his mother that he didn’t
need erasers because he didn’t make mistakes. When in truth,
he liked to chew. He couldn’t help it, and that also was the
“You’ll remember my name,” he says to her.
“I won’t,” she says. “I can forget
He knows why she says it: If she forgets his name, her destiny will
be rethought like a bad battle plan.
“What is it?” he asks. “Tell me my
“I don’t remember.” Crying, shaking.
“Say it,” he says, looking at her tan arms, pebbly with
goose bumps, the blond hair on them erect, her young breasts and
the darkness between her legs underwater.
“And the rest of it?”
“And you think that’s amusing,” he says, naked,
sitting on the lid of the toilet.
She shakes her head vigorously.
Lying. She made fun of him when he told her his name. She laughed
and said Rambo is make-believe, a movie name. He said it’s
Swedish. She said he isn’t Swedish. He said the name is
Swedish. Where did she think it came from? It’s a real name.
“Right,” she said. “Like Rocky,” she said,
laughing. “Look it up on the Internet,” he said.
“It’s a real name,” he said, and he didn’t
like that he had to explain his name. This was two days ago, and he
didn’t hold it against her, but he was aware of it. He
forgave her because despite what the world says, she suffers
“Knowing my name will be an echo,” he says. “It
makes no difference, not in the least. Just a sound already
“I would never say it.” Panic.
Her lips and nails are blue, and she shivers uncontrollably. She
stares. He tells her to drink more, and she doesn’t dare
refuse him. The slightest act of insubordination, and she knows
what happens. Even one small scream, and she knows what happens. He
sits calmly on the lid of the toilet, his legs splayed so she can
see his excitement, and fear it. She doesn’t beg anymore or
tell him to have his way with her, if that’s the reason
she’s his hostage. She doesn’t say this anymore because
she knows what happens when she insults him and implies that if he
had a way it would be with her. Meaning she wouldn’t give it
willingly and want it.
“You realize I asked you nicely,” he says.
“I don’t know.” Teeth chattering.
“You do know. I asked you to thank me. That’s all I
asked, and I was nice to you. I asked you nicely, then you had to
do this,” he says. “You had to make me do this. You
see”—he gets up and watches his nakedness in the mirror
over the smooth marble sink—“your suffering makes me do
this,” his nakedness in the mirror says. “And I
don’t want to do this. So you’ve hurt me. Do you
understand you’ve critically hurt me by making me do
this?” his nakedness in the mirror says.
She says she understands, and her eyes scatter like flying shards
of glass as he opens the toolbox, and her scattered gaze fixes on
the box cutters and knives and fine-tooth saws. He lifts out a
small bag of sand and sets it on the edge of the sink. He pulls out
ampules of lavender glue and sets them down, too.
“I’ll do anything you want. Give you anything you
want.” She has said this repeatedly.
He has ordered her not to say it again. But she just did.
His hands dip into the water, and the coldness of the water bites
him, and he grabs her ankles and lifts her up. He holds her up by
her cold, tan legs with their cold, white feet and feels her terror
in her panicking muscles as he holds her cold ankles tight. He
holds her a little longer than last time, and she struggles and
flails and thrashes violently, cold water splashing loudly. He lets
go. She gasps and coughs and makes strangling cries. She
doesn’t complain. She’s learned not to
complain—it took a while, but she’s learned it.
She’s learned all of this is for her own good and is grateful
for a sacrifice that will change his life—not hers, but
his—in a way that isn’t good. Wasn’t good. Can
never be good. She should be grateful for his gift.
He picks up the trash bag he filled with ice from the ice maker in
the bar and pours the last of it in the tub and she looks at him,
tears running down her face. Grief. The dark edges of it
“We used to hang them from the ceiling over there,” he
says. “Kick them in the sides of their knees, over and over.
Over there. All of us coming into the small room and kicking the
sides of their knees. It’s excruciatingly painful and, of
course, crippling, and, of course, some of them died. That’s
nothing compared to other things I saw over there. I didn’t
work in that prison, you see. But I didn’t need to, because
there was plenty of that type of behavior to go around. What people
don’t understand is it wasn’t stupid to film any of it.
To photograph it. It was inevitable. You have to. If you
don’t, it’s as if it never happened. So people take
pictures. They show them to others. It only takes one. One person
to see it. Then the whole world does.”
She glances at the camera on the marble-top table against the
“They deserved it anyway, didn’t they?” he says.
“They forced us to be something we weren’t, so whose
fault was it? Not ours.”
She nods. She shivers, and her teeth chatter.
“I didn’t always participate,” he says. “I
did watch. At first it was difficult, perhaps traumatic. I was
against it, but the things they did to us. And because of what they
did, we were forced to do things back, so it was their fault that
they forced us, and I know you see that.”
She nods and cries and shakes.
“The roadside bombs. Kidnapping. Much more than you hear
about,” he says. “You get used to it. Just like
you’re getting used to the cold water, aren’t
She isn’t used to it, only numb and on her way to
hypothermia. By now her head pounds and her heart feels as if it
will explode. He hands her the vodka, and she drinks.
“I’m going to open the window,” he says.
“So you can hear Bernini’s fountain. I’ve heard
it much of my life. The night’s perfect. You should see the
stars.” He opens the window and looks at the night, the
stars, the fountain of four rivers, and the piazza. Empty at this
hour. “You won’t scream,” he says.
She shakes her head and her chest heaves and she shivers
“You’re thinking about your friends. I know that.
Certainly they’re thinking about you. That’s too bad.
And they aren’t here. They aren’t anywhere to be
seen.” He looks at the deserted piazza again and shrugs.
“Why would they be here now? They’ve left. Long
Her nose runs and tears spill and she shakes. The energy in her
eyes—it’s not what it was when he met her, and he
resents her for ruining who she was to him. Earlier, much earlier,
he spoke Italian to her because it changed him into the stranger he
needed to be. Now he speaks English because it no longer makes a
difference. She glances at his excitement. Her glances at his
excitement bounce against it like a moth against a lamp. He feels
her there. She fears what’s there. But not as much as she
fears everything else—the water, the tools, the sand, the
glue. She doesn’t comprehend the thick black belt coiled on
the very old tile floor, and she should fear it most of all.
He picks it up and tells her it’s a primitive urge to beat
people who can’t defend themselves. Why? She doesn’t
answer. Why? She stares at him in terror, and the light in her eyes
is dull but crazed, like a mirror shattering right in front of him.
He tells her to stand, and she does, shakily, her knees almost
collapsing. She stands in the frigid water and he turns off the
spout. Her body reminds him of a bow with a taut string because
she’s flexible and powerful. Water trickles down her skin as
she stands before him.
“Turn away from me,” he says. “Don’t worry.
I’m not going to beat you with the belt. I don’t do
Water quietly laps in the tub as she turns away from him, facing
old, cracked stucco and a closed shutter.
“Now I need you to kneel in the water,” he says.
“And look at the wall. Don’t look at me.”
She kneels, facing the wall, and he picks up the belt and slides
the end of it through the buckle.