Advance Readers' Comments for WHISKEY AND CHARLIE
In March, a select group of readers who participated in one of our Sneak Peek Contests won copies of WHISKEY AND CHARLIE by Annabel Smith. Take a look at some of the readers' comments to give you more insight into this book... and watch out for spoilers!
Sandra C. of Fort Worth, TX
I really enjoyed the story of these twin brothers. It was real, raw and honest about the relationships we have within our families. Granted, there may be good times, but this story showed and expressed the times that a brother or sister harbors that tiny bit of jealousy, the resentment that can grow in time to almost destroy a relationship, and the repercussions of life that might not lead to a chance to reconcile or forgive one another over petty past things. It's a genuine book, one that can touch base within all of its readers. It's relatable. Any of us can be a Rosa, Juliet, Charlie or Whiskey. It's what makes us human and how we deal with the ups and downs of family life and decision making.
Rating: If 5 is the highest you can go I would give a solid 9. Only because I didn't want the book to end.
Would you recommend?: Yes. I already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I would. She is an amazing writer.
Margaret J. of Augusta, GA
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was one of the best books I've read so far this year. I average about three books a week, novels and non-fiction. Lately mostly Christian Theology and Ethics. WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was a moving, touching book. Bittersweet in the content. The clean, spare prose was so refreshing. The characters were so real! I just wanted to shake Charlie so many times in the course of the book. He reminded me of someone, until nearly the end I realized he reminded me of myself. It was a page turner! I resented having to leave it at all. I read most of it in one sitting. It wasn't that I wanted to see whether or not Whiskey woke up or was healed. I really wanted to see if Charlie healed. If Juliet healed. If Elaine healed. It was definitely a happy ending, but a bittersweet ending as well --- knowing myself, I feel certain that Charlie isn't completely different and his insecurities will surface from time to time. That's what makes him so real... he's perfectly human with all his faults and flaws. The use of the phonetic alphabet was so clever. Not heavy-handedly clever, but fun and tinged with humor clever. Sometimes life hands us a mirror so that we can see ourselves more clearly in others. It's in helping others that we find redemption. This story of brothers is a universal novel. A story of truth and health. Sad, frustrating and loving all together. A thumping good read!
Rating:On a scale of 1-5 I'd give this novel an 8. It was that good.
Would you recommend?: I'm not only recommending and giving copies of this novel to my friends, I'm insisting that my book club read it! It should provoke some great discussions for a church group!
Would you read another by Smith?: I can't wait to read more by Annabel Smith! Thoroughly enjoyed it and learned much from it.
Roe P. of Massapequa, NY
A real-life story of how we can sometimes mistake other peoples’ actions and end up with hard feelings. A line from the book describes it better than I can: "There are some things in life we never feel ready for, that is, only by doing them do we become ready."
I was immediately pulled into this story. I think it sends a strong message about taking care of the people you care about the most in your life, no matter what you have to do to make it happen. Eat crow. Be humble. Forgive. In the end, you will be a happier person, and so will your family members. The characters in this book were so alive --- as I read the book, I felt like they were people I knew. I could not put this book down until I finished it, and after I finished it, I wanted it back.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Will definitely recommend to my friends and family.
Would you read more by Smith?: I look forward to reading additional works by Annabel Smith
Sandy H. of Boxborough, MA
Everybody has someone that they are estranged from, for a variety of reasons. And sometimes it takes a tragedy to see the relationship from a different angle. These brothers, although identical twins, were very different personalities and became estranged several years ago. Tragedy brings them back together, although it certainly wasn't easy. Very interesting. Wasn't sure at first if I'd get through it but am very glad I did!
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes. I will give it to my daughter this weekend and then ask her to bring it home so that I can pass it on to my sister and mother.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Suellen B. of Lander, WY
A story of everyday people in good and bad situations, and how they cope with the problems in their lives. A great book and storyline of growing up, family and forgiveness. Engaging characters that draw you in. Even though it’s not my normal genre, I loved it.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes, I already have. My husband can’t wait to read it.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I’m definitely interested.
Mary M. of Elizabethtown, PA
The writing is excellent and there are many dynamics going on in the novel. There is the connection between twins and finding their identity. There is the theme of family and family secrets and there is the question of what constitutes a quality life, as well as how to begin to seek forgiveness of past mistakes. I related to all the characters, but identified with Charlie the most... as he struggles to understand what he and his brother mean to each other, both in the past and present.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I would definitely recommend this book to a friend.
Would you read another by Smith?: I would definitely be interested in reading future books by this author.
Michelle N. of Hillsdale, NJ
A story about the relationship between siblings, and how that relationship can undergo so many changes over the course of the years. A complicated, but heartwarming story that will really resonate with many of us who have siblings and have struggled with our own sibling relationships over the years. I loved WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. As an avid book reader, I was instantly drawn into this story of two brothers and their broken relationship over the course of their lives, and how Whiskey’s accident caused Charlie to take a step back and really think about how he wanted their relationship to be from that point on. I usually read mostly women’s fiction, or stories about families with the main characters usually being female, so I was a bit hesitant to read this book. But it was so well written, and had so many terrific characters --- from Charlie’s girlfriend, Juliet, to his adopted brother, Mike --- that I really enjoyed reading it.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Without a doubt --- I work at a public library and am involved with many book groups, and have every intention of recommending this book. So many of us can identify with sibling issues that I think this book would really make for a terrific discussion.
Would you read more by Smith?: n/a
Jan C. of Newburgh, IN
This book is a cleverly written and heart wrenching story of a family brought together by a terrible accident and the ways that they are brought together and pulled apart as they deal with family memories that are both shared and often radically remembered. You will alternately want to hug and smack the characters as they learn the lesson that sometimes, you just need to learn to live with the hand that you are dealt. And in the end, the love you share is what lets you endure.
I loved WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. I loved the honest humanity of the characters. I loved how they lived in their own "stories" and learned the seemingly obvious but hard-learned lesson that their truths overlapped. I loved the device of the radio alphabet. The connections of the chapter titles to the content were not forced, and gave me the feeling of being in on the joke and connected to the story. I thought that the emotions that the characters evinced were true in every way to their characters. I don't cry at books or movies, but I cried at the end of this one.
Rating: Strong 5
Would you recommend?: Yes! I would love for my book club to read and discuss it!
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, definitely.
Vicky B. of Trussville, AL
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is a story of identical twin brothers who are nothing alike. They become estranged, one is severely injured, and emotional mayhem rules. The heart of the story is the love this family has for each other, warts and all. I loved, loved, loved this book!
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes, I plan immediately to tell my mother and friends to read this. I am a neuro nurse and this really hits home.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would absolutely read anything Annabel will write.
Sheree C. of Fleetwood, PA
I loved this book. It grabbed me from the start. When I was reading this book, I tuned out all outside distractions --- only a really good book will allow you to do this. This is a riveting story of sibling rivalry, family dysfunction and the single tragic event that brought them back together again. This book will make you rethink your relationship with your siblings and make you want to do something to change the relationship for the better. Get ready to make contact with those dysfunctional family members you haven't heard from in years!
Rating: I would definitely give it a 5.
Would you recommend?: I have already recommended it to the women in my book group, my best friends, and I have even shared my copy with my husband, who is enjoying it as much as I did.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, most definitely! I really liked the way she wrote.
Cam G. of Murrells Inlet, SC
Whiskey and Charlie are identical twins torn apart by jealousies and sibling rivalry. It takes a devastating accident to one of them for them to become as close as they once were.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I already have. My friend has a daughter living in Australia, and thought my friend would very much enjoy it!
Would you read more by Smith?: Absolutely!
Betty T. of Warner Robins, GA
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE presents a very realistic view of a family dealing with a tragic event, sibling rivalry and jealousies, the insecurities of people, and the strengths found in tough times. The characters felt so real that I wouldn't mind having them as friends. The story progressed at a pace that let me get to know them and feel their pains and joys.
At first I was a bit put off by the chapter titles gimmick. Lately, it seems some authors spend more time on developing their format than on the story itself. But I am happy to say I was wrong when it comes to Annabel Smith. As children, Whiskey and Charlie loved the NATO alphabet, so Ms. Smith wrote 26 chapters with each chapter named for the next letter of the alphabet. Thus the chapters were Alpha, Bravo, Charlie, Delta, etc. Having a military background, I had no problem keeping up with the chapters. The story flowed really well, and I found myself wondering how she was going to work the title of the chapter into the story, especially with chapters such as India, Kilo, Lima, Quebec, and Uniform. Amazingly, she accomplished it very smoothly. I found myself really impressed with how she worked the titles seemingly so effortlessly into the story. I found myself drawn in, easily relating to the ups and downs. The family dynamics are so realistic. I could really relate with many of the family issues addressed in this book. The characters were so human. I loved them, I felt their pain. I wanted to shake some of them; I wanted to hug some.
The creation of Charlie was so well done. Ms. Smith took us through his childhood, during which he felt inferior to Whiskey. We only get to know Whiskey through the eyes of the other characters. So the evolution of the story mostly revolves around Charlie, who feels so guilty about his relationship with his twin brother. With Whiskey in a coma, he is afraid he will never have the chance to tell his brother that in spite of their problems, he still loves him. I loved Rosa, Whiskey’s wife, and Juliet, Charlie’s girlfriend. Rosa pulled no punches at any time. Her directness was very endearing. Juliet seemed a bit too perfect --- beautiful and extremely patient --- but I still loved the character.
The story progressed. At times I wanted it to move faster, but that was only because I wanted to know what was coming next. The characters developed at a pace that let me get to know them and feel the issues they had to work through. Nothing was rushed and I was grateful for that. I wanted to take that ride along with Charlie to see how it would all turn out. I was not disappointed.
Rating: 5, definitely.
Would you recommend?: Yes. I think most people can relate to the family dynamics. The unique chapter titles are actually fun to watch as she worked them into the story.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes!
Monica J. of Austin, TX
I loved this book and the way it was constructed. I really liked how the chapters centered on the NATO alphabet, and how the story unfolded in bits and pieces of the memories of one character. Although it is told from the point of view of Charlie, it is so easy to imagine the thoughts and feelings of all of the major players in the book. It is a very realistic look at the way people contemplate life in the face of tragedy. As a grandmother of twins, the topic of twins' relationships is quite interesting. The book brought me to tears at the end. Everyone needs a Rosa in their life!
This is a very thought provoking book about family, love, and forgiveness. It is written in a unique way, so that the lives of the characters unfolds much like it is when getting to know someone. So many challenges that people run into in a lifetime are in this book and are presented in a way that creates empathy for all of the characters.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I already have. I loved this book and hope several of my friends/family members read it!
Would you read more by Smith?: Absolutely --- in fact, I will be looking for A NEW MAP OF THE UNIVERSE.
Barbara M. of Mohawk, NY
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is a book that offers characters you come to care about, characters who are relatable, and a story that could easily be about anyone's family. This book is about brothers who start out as best of friends but grow apart as they age and go their separate way in the world. It's about one brother finding his way back to the other after almost losing that chance forever.
I really enjoyed the style of writing. I thought the use of the radio alphabet was original and worked really well for this book. I could just imagine the boys playing with their walkie-talkies and using the radio alphabet as their form of communication. I think the twins could be anyone's sons or brothers. They are so relatable on so many levels. It was a pleasure to see Charlie's growth and watch him find his love for his brother again (even though he could be annoying and frustrating)!
Rating: 5 --- loved it!
Would you recommend?: Definitely yes and already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes! I really like her writing style. I'll definitely keep an "author watch" on her.
Simonne C. of Acushnet, MA
A fast moving story of twin brothers who develop different personalities and do not remain close as adults. A tragic accident brings Charlie back into Whiskey's life... and he hopes, as does the reader, that it is not too late. The characters are well-formed: Elaine, Rosa, Juliet, Bill, Mike, and of course Whiskey and Charlie. I really liked it. I found it very thought provoking. [SPOILERS] It was brilliant to change the reader's sympathy from Charlie's point of view to aligning themselves with Whiskey. [END SPOILERS.]
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes
Would you read more by Smith?: Certainly.
Patricia R. of Henderson, NV
This is a poignant, heartfelt, beautifully written story of forgiveness and redemption involving twin brothers. Each chapter uses a word (starting in descending order) of the NATO phonetic alphabet, and these words are tied thematically to the chapter's content. The twins' relationship with each other unfolds slowly until the last chapter in which Charlie gains much needed insight.
I was intrigued by the characters being identical twins and having their own way of communication. I, too, am an identical twin, and, like Whiskey and Charlie, my twin and I used code words when we were young. Although we did not use the NATO phonetic alphabet, we had our own set of made-up words which only we two could understand. My sister's personality was similar to Whiskey's, while mine was more like Charlie's. She was the risk taker and trail blazer, while I conformed and did what was expected of me. Moreover, when we were young, we were very close but gradually grew apart in college. We had a major falling out during our middle years and have since reconciled. I felt as if Annabel Smith either knew identical twins very intimately or had done lots of research on them. As a direct result of reading this novel, I decided to reach out more often to my sister and to fully accept her as she is today.
Rating: 5 stars!
Would you recommend?: Yes. I have already recommended this book to my book club, teacher friends, and friends at the gym. Just about anyone who has a strained relationship with a family member will relate to what Charlie is going through during Whiskey's medical crisis.
Would you read more by Smith?: Most definitely yes! She writes a compelling and emotionally charged narrative with well-depicted characters and a keen insight in the human condition.
Michelle C. of Omaha, Nebraska
This was a story about family, forgiveness, and hope. It was very well written and I really appreciated Smith's ability to write realistic dialogue throughout every situation. The characters, their flaws, and their tough journeys as they worked through them alone and with each other felt very honest and real. I really enjoyed this book.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes, I already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: Absolutely!
Rosalie C. of Georgetown, KY
This book grabbed me from the first pages! Loved it. It is about family, misconceptions, learning to deal with terminal illness, the importance of friends, marriage/divorce and children. The two-way language of the siblings lays the foundation for the entire story --- filled with flashbacks and realizations of what is and what could have been, and the fact that all is not always what one thinks it is! It is about sibling rivalry and finally coming to grips with oneself.
Rating: Definitely a 5!
Would you recommend?:I think the book has meaning and relevance for everyone --- especially parents, siblings, counselors, medical care professionals, and best friends.
Would you read more by Smith?:Most definitely! I really believe WHISKEY AND CHARLIE has the possibility of a sequel --- or perhaps a movie!
Mary Lee O. of Lincoln, NE
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was a book that seemed to start very slow for me. Once into the book, though, I couldn’t put it down. I liked that the author was able to keep the many Australian ways of talking, etc., to make the book seem more realistic.
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE tells the story of identical twin brothers, who are like the members of many families: they love each other and despise each other. But in the end, when it really counts, Charlie is there to help his brother recover his life and his memories.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes I would recommend it to a friend. In fact, I intend to recommend it to my book club for a future read.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I would be interested in reading other books by Annabel Smith.
Angela S, of Williston Park, NY
I absolutely loved this book. From the first page, I knew I would not be able to put it down. It’s about identical twins who are quite opposite in character, yet unbeknownst to other, have the same inner feelings. Told in both present and flashback sequences, at one point you like one brother, despise the other, and then have the exact opposite feelings. What you think and believe is not necessarily the way things really are. You need to express yourself. (I do, however, take an exception to the Hall & Oates comment Smith makes. I'm an avid H&O fan and am always getting kidded about it!)
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I would heartily recommend this book. The story of siblings is so real, and could be applied to any gender.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would be interested in reading other books. She has a fluidity in her writing that makes it easy to read and yet delves into your inner psyche.
Jennifer I. of Richmond, MI
It resonates inside of me, like viewing a rare gem or hearing a song from my childhood. That is the feeling this book gave me.WHISKEY AND CHARLIE starts out as a book about identical twin brothers and ends being about who makes up a family, whether related by blood or not. It takes the reader through relationship issues via Charlie's viewpoint. And in the end, you may not get what you want for the family. Instead, you get something better.
Rating: 5. This is the kind of story that stays with you long after you have turned the last page.
Would you recommend?: Yes I would, because the characters in this book are different from each other and I know my reading friends could relate to at least one of the characters.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes, absolutely. I'm adding her to my author list of favorites.I will be leaving reviews on Amazon and Goodreads. Thank you!
Heather F. of Rumford, RI
I thought this was an amazing, well written story with a storyline that is all so true. This book teaches us about family, sibling love and the reality of growing up and apart and suddenly realizing what is truly important in life.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I will recommend this book to many because of the subject matter.
Would you read another by Smith?: I would love to read more by Annabel Smith. Her writing is so smooth and enjoyable
Rosemary K. of Willoughby, OH
I loved this story. The characters were realistic and I could understand their feelings and emotions. WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is an emotional story that explores the relationship between two twins. Charlie's bond with his brother is broken by jealousy and envy. Then a devastating accident to Whiskey brings home the realization that we shouldn't bury our feelings because you never know what the future holds. Charlie must now face the fact that he might never be able to repair his relationship with Whiskey.
Rating: A strong 5
Would you recommend?: I already mentioned this book to several of my friends, but I want to stress that I did not and will not lend my ARC. The book paints a realistic picture. It made me realize that life is too short to hold a grudge.
Would you read another by Smith?: I would love to read more by Annabel Smith. She has a wonderful writing style. Her story flows effortlessly and her characters have a realism that made it easy for me to connect with them.
Kristy B. of Flower Mound, TX
I loved WHISKEY AND CHARLIE! I really enjoyed how the author used the phonetic alphabet to mold each chapter. It made the chapters memorable and I learned the phonetic alphabet! It is about twin brothers who have a very complicated relationship which is explored through chapters molded through their special language of the phonetic alphabet. Each chapter introduces another aspect of their relationship and Charlie's growth (or lack of).
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I would, and I have recommended it to several friends. Although it was an easy read, it had a lot of emotional substance about relationships.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes!
Gloria R. of Parma, OH
I thought the book was a very, very interesting book. I took so many twists and turns I never could have seen or guessed where it was going --- even when it was on the way, never could I have imagined where it was going. WHISKEY & CHARLIE is the story of a set of twins who are as alike as "day and night." They remind me of my twin brothers. One is the "good" twin and one the "adventurous" one, always doing his own thing. They lived their lives together through babyhood, elementary school, high school and then on to adulthood until one day something happens to Whiskey that puts him in a coma --- we don't know what. The book is about how everyone around Whiskey tries to resolve their own lives and his.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I would and have recommended the book to several friends. The why is because it is so interesting, and has so many twists and turns that it is almost impossible to explain to anyone.
Would you read another by Smith?: I most definitely would be interested in reading another Annabel Smith. I would be interested to see how she outdid herself.
Heather G. of Milton, DE
I think the book was fantastic. I would describe the book as one that shows us into the minds of these characters. The book is based on the two children Whiskey and Charlie, and their bonds with each other. It shows how specific things done as children can affect them later on.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I would recommend this book to a friend because it is a likable book. The author did a good job of making very strong characters.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes, I would read something else by Annabel Smith.
Nancy G. of Minneapolis, MN
I enjoyed it very much. This is a story about identical twins that grow up to not like each other very much. It weaves in side stories of the relationships with parents, girlfriends, wives, and good friends, and the coping skills needed to maintain those relationships. Ultimately, the story is about the twins, and how a horrible accident shows that they are more alike than not.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I already have. It's a great read about relationships.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes, I would love to read more by her.
Michaelene P. of Rolling Meadows, IL
This is a book about an imperfect family in crisis. The use of the two-way radio alphabet as the chapter titles reminds me of the book THE CURIOUS INCIDENT OF THE DOG IN THE NIGHT-TIME, and they have such meaning. If you have ever had a rift with a friend or family member this book will resonate!
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I have already recommended it to two friends and am getting a copy for a friend's birthday.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would love to read more books by Annabel Smith.
Iva R. of Fairdale, KY
This is a story of identical twin brothers from the perspective of the "younger" twin, Charlie. A life-threatening accident makes Charlie grow as a person, bringing him closer to his twin brother as well as other friends and family members.
I loved WHISKEY AND CHARLIE! I was a bit frustrated with Charlie at points in the story, but then I realized why he was thinking/acting the way he was. I loved all of the characters. I could relate somewhat, because I have two sons. I cried at times, especially after Whiskey's accident when Charlie was remembering good times between them as children. I'm glad that Charlie grew as a person, and decided if he could just get his brother back, the past was just that: the past.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Yes, and I already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, absolutely!
Brenda T. of Farmington Hills, MI
Twin boys, Whiskey and Charlie, grew up with Whiskey being more popular and successful. Charlie is jealous of this, and stops seeing him. Whiskey is in a coma from a car accident when Charlie rethinks his decisions.
I spent most of the book rooting for Charlie, and thinking, why did he do that? Whiskey had eroded his self-esteem to a point where he could not make any good decisions for himself. [SPOILERS] Whiskey's coma with Charlie's decision to change was super. Mike was a very good brother/friend to help Charlie. And Charlie and Juliet are engaged. Very good ending. [END SPOILERS.]
Rating: 5+
Would you recommend?: Yes, I already have. Very good book.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would enjoy reading more books by Annabel Smith.
Claire D. of Medford, NY
This book deals with mistakes we make along the way in our relationships with family and friends, and the emotional impact of them. How do we handle the possibility that there might not be a chance to make amends? How do we come to an understanding of our motivations and actions? I loved, loved this book! I found myself not being able to put it down, yet trying to read it slowly so it wouldn't end.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: I already have recommended it! This book will appeal to everyone, because the themes of family relationships, reaction to adversity, and factors that influence self-image are universally appealing.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, definitely!
Diana T. of Staten Island, NY
A story of regret, redemption and familial love. When his estranged identical twin brother Whiskey goes into a coma, Charlie has to face that he himself is also to blame for the bad relationship that developed between the two formally inseparable brothers. Charlie's journey and the way it affects every relationship in his life and helps him grow up and go forward is the resolution in this story. I absolutely loved this book. It was a page turner not because it was a mystery, but because it was so fascinating.
Rating: 5
Would you recommend?: Absolutely! The characters were all interesting.
Would you read more by Smith?: n/a
Ginny H. of Troutdale, OR
This is a wonderful depiction of the love and devotion of two brothers; in this case, twins, and the way in which their relationship became very complicated. When one suffers a terrible accident, the other must come to terms with the aftermath.
I loved WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. I thought it had heart and introspection and I was able to share in the transformation of a flawed but well-meaning human soul.
Rating: I would rate this between a 4 and a 5.
Would you recommend?: I definitely would recommend this book and already have. Because of the theme, I would like to share this with my other siblings, one of whom I thought about the whole time I was reading this book.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I will look for other books by this author. I thought WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was wonderfully written.
Anne B. of Albuquerque, NM
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was memorable, unforgettable, captivating and meaningful. It tugged at my heartstrings and resonated with me greatly. Relationships between siblings are always fraught with tension and difficulties, but with twins this happens even more so. This profound novel strikes at the heart and soul with great depth.
Rating: 4.5
Would you recommend?: Yes.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Terese T. of Old Hickory, TN
I loved this book. It was a fairly quick read and kept my interest throughout. First of all, having worked in the airline industry for many years, I enjoyed how each chapter used one of the letters of the communication alphabet as the theme. And it is perfect that the alphabet figures so prominently in the relationship between the brothers. No one would wish such a tragedy on anyone, but the book really made me realize all of the nuances, dilemmas and relationship crises that can and most probably would occur in this sort of case. I was rooting for Charlie and Whiskey to reconcile and was not disappointed.
Rating: 4.5
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would most definitely recommend, and in fact I already have. My recommendation was based on the readability and great storyline.
Would you read more by Smith?: Absolutely!
Mary W. of Millbury, MA
I loved this book. I couldn't put it down and read it in three days. The book is about the trials and tribulations of growing up with an identical twin. Each brother has his own way in the world, but when an accident puts one in a coma, the other starts to look at his brother’s life in a completely different manner. It also touches on tough decisions, and how a complex family decides to deal with them.
Rating: 4.5
Would you recommend?: I already have two people waiting to read it. It reminded me of the great book by Jojo Moyes, ME BEFORE YOU.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would read anything this woman wrote. Great job, Annabel Smith!
Maleen C. of St. Louis, MO
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is a story of twin brothers complicated by long-held, unresolved issues they both carried into adulthood --- only now one is in a coma and the other is unable to communicate what he would like to his sleeping brother. Actually, communication is a key theme in the book. As boys, Whiskey and Charlie had walkie-talkies and used the NATO phonetic alphabet to speak to each other in a secret language. Annabel Smith took that same alphabet, word by word, to create a story of love, frustration, compassion, and redemption. It is a story I will not soon forget.
I thought the book began rather slowly, but when I got to the chapter “Lima,” it began to roll, with Rosa and all that she set into motion. I liked Mike --- he provided a sort of calm/relief to the tension created by all of the other aspects of the story. The whole “Victor” chapter was probably the strongest/most powerful part of the book. Those pages pushed and pulled and tugged and tore the whole coma concept apart, exposing every aspect of it. Overall, I thought the book was cleverly crafted, using the phonetic alphabet as the skeleton to flesh out a fairly dramatic story.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, I already have, because I think it is a story that has a lot to say on many levels.
Would you read more by Smith?: Certainly.
Steph E. of Duluth, MN
WHISKEY & CHARLIE is about two twins who are quite different --- one outgoing, one kind of shy, always the one trying to shame or out do the other. They choose different paths in life, and at some point they lose touch like families do, but there is a lot of anger and resentment as well. There is some closure at the end. Great story about a complicated relationship. A very quick and easy read. I really enjoyed the book.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would recommend this book to a friend.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Lelia P. of Long Island City, NY
There is nothing like life or death accidents to draw reflection upon our relationships with others. That is how we come to meet identical twin brothers William (Whiskey) and Charlie Ferns. Whiskey has been in a terrible accident that has left him in a comatose state. Holding vigil at Whiskey’s bedside, Charlie has little to do but ponder the events that have rendered him and his brother estranged. Charlie’s unflinching honesty lends itself to a tale of sibling rivalry in a dysfunctional family, who are now all doing their best to hold onto hope for Whiskey’s survival. Annabel Smith delivers a poignant tale of self-exploration in a time of grief. WHISKEY AND CHARLIE offers the reader a lovely message about accepting our authentic selves, but more importantly, for allowing others to be who they are and not what we expect or want them to be.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: I already have. I believe this book offers something for everyone. I have recommended that my son read it as well, as he is good friends with twin boys.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I would be interested to read more by Annabel Smith.
David R. of Newark, DE
This is a story about twin boys who fought in the growing up stage, to the point where they were at odds with each other. Then one adult twin has a medical issue that could cause death, and his survival is questionable. This causes the other adult twin to question his life actions around his brother, and in the process, change his beliefs about himself and his brother. We should all reflect on our interactions with others so that we will not regret what we have done when the end is near.
I thought WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was a thought provoking story about growing up, about things that you do that are not helpful to yourself or others, and how a major event causes you to reflect on how you dealt with issues and people. The characters in the book helped string the events together, like they could happen in real life. I did find it fun that Smith named the chapters after the spoken alphabet used by short-wave radio and walkie-talkie folks, and to see how that came about after the twins got walkie-talkies.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes to some friends, and maybe to other friends. This is a personal life story, and some of my friends like romance stories, or intrigue mysteries.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes, I would.
Mary H. of Granbury, TX
This is a story of family --- primarily twin brothers, but also the rest of the family, both close and more distant. Through flashbacks, we learn of the early years of Whiskey and Charlie, and how the two brothers came to be where they were as adults. The perceptions of one twin --- of each other as well as of other members of the family --- change as situations change, just as in real life.
I found the book very interesting, and especially liked the use of the Alpha Bravo alphabet for the chapter headings, since my husband and I used to fly to travel various places and he used those call letters a lot. It brought back memories of trips we made.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would definitely recommend it to my friends and plan to do so. I am a member of three different book groups, and I know I will be suggesting it to at least two of those groups.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would certainly hope this author writes more books for us to read.
Alan K. of Mount Vernon, GA
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is the story of a twin struggling with familial relationships, particularly with his brother who, when we meet him, is on life support in the hospital. Charlie’s issues in his own life, we learn as the book progresses, begin to appear connected at some level, and perhaps even all tie back to his sense of inferiority or “second place” in his family as the smaller and slightly younger twin brother. He attempts to cope with what he must accept as the possible end of his brother’s life, and is forced to reconcile his own feelings about the past, his brother, his father, his girlfriend, and even himself. Over time, his views of his brother change, and he changes as well. It’s a good family story that unfolds in an interesting but not entirely predictable manner. It draws the reader in but the outcome is in jeopardy until very near the end.
I really enjoyed WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. I read more non-fiction than fiction, so when I look for something unrelated to management, business, or science, I try to find good stories about people with whom I can relate. After the relationships between the brothers in the book began to unfold, I was drawn into the story of the perceptions Charlie had about his brother, and the eventual transformation of his views about Whiskey, his family, and commitment.
I found no real weaknesses in the story, and even enjoyed the somewhat slow pace in which she revealed the other characters. For example, it took us a while to get to know anything about Rosa, but we learned that she had clearly changed Whiskey’s life. Then their brother, Mike, enters and, in some ways, appeared to be more of a brother to Whiskey than Charlie.
I especially enjoyed the descriptive language Smith uses. She writes colorfully and descriptively about the look of the hospital, making you feel as if you are there. She does the same with her memories of the boys’ youthful escapades.
Rating: On a scale of 1-5, I’d give the book a 4, maybe even a 4.5.
Would you recommend?: I would absolutely recommend the book to a friend, and have already done so.
Would you read more by Smith?: I’d very much enjoy reading other works by Annabel Smith. WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was very well done. I hope it becomes a rousing success!
Cherry W. of Dallas, TX
A slice of life book about twin brothers who were never close. One is gravely injured and the other is forced to take stock of his life and relationship with his brother.
This wasn't a book I couldn't wait to get back to reading, but when I did, I enjoyed it. And while I wasn't that “into it,” I have found myself thinking about the two brothers I feel it is an honest appraisal of many sibling relationships as all too often, they get caught up in past slights/arguments and can't seem to see the changes in each other until it is too late. This is what I saw with Charlie. He had a picture of Whiskey in his mind and couldn't see his growth as he matured. Yet Charlie was mired in the muck of feeling “less than” and couldn't seem to move his life forward.
Rating: I give it a solid 4
Would you recommend?: Yes. I want to know what my friends think about this book. A different question: Would I choose this for Book Club? No.
Would you read more by Smith?: Maybe. I would certainly look closely at future books before making a decision.
Sue L. of Nashua, NH
This is a book about a relationship between two brothers and how they, their family, and their friends see their relationship --- how a tragedy makes you review and rethink your life, feelings, and thoughts of the past, and how finding out how others saw it can really change you.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: I would recommend this book to friends. I think it would make a very good read for book clubs.
Would you read more by Smith?: n/a
Martha V. of Remlap, AL
Story of a set of twins growing up and older, of similarities, differences and conflicts. Really good book.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes. Very good for someone 40+ who can relate to younger/older days.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Dan K. of Andover, NJ
Whiskey and Charlie are twin brothers who seem to be opposites, which strains their relationship as adults. But when Whiskey is in an accident that results in a coma, Charlie begins to doubt himself and his relationships. I enjoyed the complex relationship between the brothers. Being a brother myself, I can relate (not to the coma portion of the story, but to growing up).
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would and I have. Why? Because it is a heartfelt story about familiar relationships and the strain on individuality.
Would you read more by Smith?: Certainly.
Sherrie E. of Bloomfield, MI
A fantastic story represented and supported with wonderful characters. A story of a faithful family, not always on the same page all the time, but loving and faithful. A story that truly looks at forgiveness, of ourselves and of family. A story in which we can each see a piece of ourselves in one or more of the characters. They will reach into your heart, and you will root for them all through the story.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: I already have. :)
Would you read more by Smith?: Absolutely!
Marjorie S. of Woodridge, IL
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE presents some universal themes regarding being a member of a family and communication. It is an interesting view of the relationship between twins.
The book was a compelling read. The characters were interesting and human. The radio alphabet element was cleverly done, emphasizing the communication and lack of between the brothers. I think all siblings remember their childhoods differently, and it is only in hindsight that we recognize the actual events which have been colored by things like our place in the family, relationships with parents, and events that occurred. The juxtaposition of present and past events made it easy to empathize with Charlie, but by the end I understood Whiskey as well. It made me reconsider events in my life. I know several sets of twins, and can see now some of the things that will mold them as they grow up.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Mary H. of Avon, CT
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is a simple story with a deep message. Every chapter unfolds into a short story of its own. It is a story of a real family: the sharing, the love, the problems, the sadness, the joys, and most of all the bonding that only exists when love is present.
I would like to point out one error. In regard to Rosa not wanting to remove Whiskey from life support because she is Catholic. There is no rule in the Catholic Church that states any artificial means must be used to prolong life. The rule is that life cannot be hastened, one must die naturally. Tubes, plug-ins, etc. are not natural means.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would recommend this story
Would you read more by Smith?: I enjoyed Annabel Smith's characterization. Her characters came to life for me. I would read other books by her.
Toni G. of New Hartford, CT
A cunning foxtrot of a book. Interesting novel about what it means to be part of a family, an emotional journey to adulthood, flaws and jealousies and fears. Thanks for sharing this book! Will be watching for more by Ms. Smith.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes.
Julie B. of Martinton, IL.
I loved this book! The characters were alive, the storyline was gripping, and the author evoked emotion with almost every word! I fell in love with the boys. Every now and again, you read a book that sticks with you, that applies to your life and resonates with your soul. This is that book. I am having my kids read it now, and hopefully they can pull from it the same life lessons! A story that could be your story. A great read!
Rating: I give this book 4 stars
Would you recommend?: I have already recommended it to friends and family.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes! I will definitely read other books by this author! Amazing.
Pam M. of Waukesha, WI
I’m only about halfway through the book but am enjoying it so far. It’s a story about two brothers who grow up close, then they “disconnect” and a life/death situation causes re-examination of their relationship.
Rating:Maybe a 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, it’s a good book about family dynamics and drama.
Would you read another by Smith?: n/a
Patti D. of Waukesha, WI
I liked the story. It is a difficult topic. I come from a big family and have six siblings. I have two brothers who were born 15 months apart. They had their own language together when they were very young, were connected all the time, and as they got older, the completion grew. Our father favored one over the other, which caused big problems later. This book makes one realize that life can be cut short at any time. Reconnect with your family and friends before you can't go back.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes, it is a good story. Sibling rivalry is real in families and it can tear apart close sibling over jealousy, feeling not good enough as the other and feelings of not getting the same attention.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes.
Marion M. of Fox Lake, WI
Loved it! Very emotional. At times I didn’t want to put it down. Had lessons in it that we could all draw from.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: I already have.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes --- I have not read any of her other works. Will look into now that I read this one.
Amy N. of Grove City, OH
I found it very enjoyable. The use of the International Phonetic Alphabet to head each chapter was clever. Each chapter woven together in beautiful story telling. This is the story of two brothers, twins, estranged as adults until one of them is in an accident. It's told from the story of the non-injured brother, and alternates from past to present as he struggles with the hope of repairing their relationship before it’s too late.
Rating: 4
Would you recommend?: Yes. I think all of us have experienced times where we wished we had said things to loved ones when we had the chance. I think most people would find something in this story that they can relate to.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes.
Melanie S. of Laurel Hollow, NY
A sensitive story about identical twin brothers who are far from identical in their personalities. We are first introduced to the brothers when, as adults, one is visiting the other, who has sustained a severe head injury and is in a coma. We learn about Whiskey and Charlie and their relationship/rivalry from a very early age through their teenage years and adulthood. After Whiskey's accident, Charlie must shed his self-righteous attitude toward his brother to move forward.
The book started off rather slowly but then built momentum, and I found myself more engaged as the story progressed. A satisfying and emotional read that definitely improved as it went along.
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: I would say that maybe I would recommend this book to a friend.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would certainly read another book by this author.
Lynn H. of Centreville, VA
This is the story of twin brothers who are very different from each other and have grown apart. One is now in a coma; and the other is trying to come to terms with the situation.
When the book first arrived, I read the back cover to remind myself of what the book was going to be about and then opened it right up. The minute I saw the table of contents, I knew I was going to enjoy it. So creative! And then the ability to weave the story around the alphabet so smoothly was simply amazing. It always fit yet never felt forced.
The storyline itself had potential to become sappy on a few occasions but I never felt that it did. I'm still not sure how I feel about the ending --- in some ways I feel like everything was resolved too neatly, with too many happy endings --- and yet, it's the outcome I wanted, so how can I complain?
Rating: 3.5
Would you recommend?: I already have. I think this is a story everyone can relate to in some way. Even those that are the only child will find things to relate to in the various relationships.
Would you read more by Smith?: I would. I see great potential in her ability to write.
Jessica M. of Round Mountain, NV
WHISKEY AND CHARLIE is an exploration of what it means to be a brother and a friend. It also portrays the ways people drift apart, and how circumstances can change in a moment that may alter your perspective of what you thought you understood about another person.
Overall I liked WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. Sometimes I liked both brothers, sometimes I didn't like either one. I feel it was told with an honest approach of how people, especially family members, treat each other.
Rating: 3.5
Would you recommend?: I would recommend this book to friends that like the topics of contemporary family drama and complicated relationships.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Rochelle B. of Agoura Hills, CA
A terrible accident brings two estranged twin brothers back together again as family. The course this takes is both realistic and emotionally unsparing.
On the whole, I thought WHISKEY AND CHARLIE was well-written, with well-developed characters. I did feel it would have benefited from better editing. Some of the side stories meandered, and were not essential to the central story of the novel. I think this may have happened because the author chose a somewhat restrictive structure using the NATO alphabet system and needed to cover the whole alphabet.
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: I might recommend it to a friend, because I thought it raised important points about the contrition one feels when a loved one is about to pass or passes. It deals very well with this important point.
Would you read more by Smith?: I think I might be interested.
Sue G. of Arvada, CO
Book was fair to good. There is lots of drama.
Rating: 3+
Would you recommend?: I already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: n/a
Phoebe A. of Eden Prairie, MN
I found the book to be a quick, easy, and intriguing read. I could relate to the characters. Though family members can love and care for one another, there are always situations ripe for conflict, if for no other reason than the "characters" know each other so/too well. [SPOILERS] In addition, most families have some secret(s) in the family lineage, even if they say they do not. [END SPOILERS.] Also, any family members' lives can turn on a dime, causing relationships to either diverge or deepen.Brotherly bonds that became bent, bitter and broken over time are brought back to the basics of love and care, and to what really matters in life, by a life on the line. In a twist, the brother bond becomes a central piece of the plot. Family, with all its foibles, failures and floundering, is still family, and forgiveness can make us forget the former while focusing on the future, especially when fate intervenes.
Rating: n/a
Would you recommend?: Yes. For reasons I've mentioned above as well as how the chapters’ titles tie in to the way WHISKEY AND CHARLIE communicated as young boys.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes.
Kirsten G. of Wallingford, CT
I really enjoyed it. I was intrigued immediately by the titles of the chapters. When I first read the chapter titles, I didn't understand what they stood for. I only noticed they were in alphabetical order and very clever. Once I started reading the book and saw the story behind the titles, I flipped back to the beginning to read them all. This book was a great story examining the different relationships Charlie and Whiskey had with the people in their lives, and each other. What I loved the most was that it was realistic. There was no miraculous recovery, no unrealistic ending. This was a story that could actually happen. Every event was believable. I loved how the story showed each character and the different ways they were dealing with what had happened to Whiskey. The other brother threw me a little, but once I got used to him and his daughters I came to understand his part of the story. He really helped Charlie deal with his emotional process. Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: Yes, and I already have! It was an intriguing book, and one that made me want to keep reading to see what would happen.
Would you read another by Smith?: Yes.
Patricia M. of Wakarusa, IN
I liked WHISKEY AND CHARLIE. I related to it on a personal level, because my sister and I had a huge falling out several years back and haven't yet recovered from it. So it really made me think how I would feel if something like this happened. I like her writing style. It kept me engaged throughout the book. I guess my only criticism would be that it seems sometimes like she added in short storylines just to fit in with the chapter titles. [SPOILERS] For example, when she introduced the nephew Oscar --- for that chapter he says how he became inseparable with Oscar. But yet, you rarely hear him mentioned through the rest of the book. And I was a little confused by the ending. At the very end, when all of a sudden Whiskey seems to talk normally (whereas up to that point it seemed like he could barely speak), what does that mean? Did he suddenly recover? I wasn't sure exactly how things ended. [END SPOILERS.]
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: Yes, I would. It was entertaining and made me think.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes I would.
Lynda T. of Bloomington, MN
Twin brothers grow apart. After tragedy strikes, can they get back together, or is it too late for them?
The first third of the book, I thought it was really dull, and kept waiting for more background information on the characters to find out why they acted the way they did. Once it got moving, I enjoyed the story more, but I never really warmed up to Charlie as a character. I find it hard to believe in last-minute transformations of characters.
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: I talked about this book at lunch at work the other day.
Would you read more by Smith?: It would depend on the book synopsis.
Laure F. of Indianapolis, IN
The story is about a complicated relationship between two identical twins. They used to get along when little, but the relationship broke down. Whiskey has an accident which leaves him in a coma and which leads Charlie to re-examine his relationship with his brother. Over time, Charlie realizes that he was partly at fault for the breakdown in the relationship, which allows him to move forward and help to mend their differences.
I liked the characters in the book, especially Rosa and Juliet, and thought they were well-developed. I could relate to them. I found the relationship between the two brothers interesting, and liked how Charlie came to the realization that the breakdown in their relationship was a two-way street, and that he had not been perfect in his dealings with, and judgment of, Whiskey. At times I felt the dialogue was a bit stilted, and that the author was trying too hard to get the reader to reach the conclusion she wanted to be reached.
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: I already have.
Would you read more by Smith?: Yes.
Sonya M. of Jasper, TX
A tale of identical twins, emotionally very different people, who find themselves in a complicated struggle to prove just how different they are. A crisis draws one to the bedside of the other. One struggles to find his way back to the living while the other struggles to find his way back into his brother's life.
I was very caught up in the beginning. The characters were vivid and the plot interesting and believable. I began to sympathize with Charlie and to dislike Whiskey, as the author wished. I also enjoyed the way the book was divided, with alternating chapters covering the progression of the boys' lives and also Whiskey's accident --- although I felt it was a mistake to wait so long to reveal what happened. It felt natural to follow Charlie as he meandered through life behind the star trail that was his brother's path. Charlie's desperate attempts to make his own way made it evident to me that he would have to grab for more than a brass ring before he would feel he was his own man.
[SPOILERS] Where I began to lose patience was in the middle of "Uniform." Charlie's jealousy and reluctance to marry rang true, but what was the point of making the "love interest" so grotesque? The introduction of Mike and his family also felt false --- what was the real purpose? Then, on pages 238-239, the author shovels out Charlie's feelings about Mike, with little or no development. When did he struggle with all of these emotions and analyze them so he could arrive at these conclusions? Then we meet our next grotesque --- poor Victor, who suggests they think about pulling the plug. All villains do not have to be hunchbacks who cross-dress for us to get the notion that the ideas they are proposing are abhorrent. But I did think this line of the plot was a continuation of one begun earlier in the book, with the dog who was hit by the car. Improbably, it seems that Charlie would have been the one to decide if the dog was hurt too badly to live (the vet proposes surgery and says, "Your mother thinks we should give it a go, but she said it's up to you"). So I assumed that the main plot line would lead to this, that Charlie, along with the rest of his family, would find out there are seldom third and fourth chances to right wrongs --- that most of us must come to terms with our own mistakes and shortcomings and then help each other deal with such a crisis. I expected Charlie to have to pull the plug. Whiskey in a wheelchair repeating their old alphabet just felt too contrived. I agree with the Kirkus review that this is "a powerful, emotionally riven tale of a brother's deep, complicated love," and perhaps I liked what I read in the beginning so much that the problems I felt I stumbled over midway prevented me from enjoying the end. I think I expected something larger and more dramatic. Perhaps I just did not read it at the right time.
Rating: 3
Would you recommend?: Yes. I have given it to my mother to read. I think she will enjoy the storyline, and she loves a happy ending.
Would you read more by Smith?: Quite possibly.
Jan Z. of Fort Pierce, FL
This is a book with a focus of the differing worlds of close siblings. Obviously, they differ, but in this case, we only get the feelings and voice of one of the siblings.
The beginning was very confusing as to location. Were they in England? Australia? Took several chapters to sort this out.
[SPOILERS] The author tried to throw in everything, hoping something would stick --- gays, sibling rivalry, affairs, fear of marriage, unknown stranger-brother, early pregnancy of the mother and the terms of her marriage, uncertainty about careers, fear of marriage, etc. The author did not include AIDS/HIV. I kept expecting it to appear. What was the point/benefit of including a gay man? What was the point of having the uncle complete suicide? What was the point of the father marrying a young woman in England and having a child? The idea of using a childhood game or character from a book when someone is recovering from brain damage is not new, and it was so obviously going to be used because of the giveaway with the chapter titles. [END SPOILERS.]
I just found this book to be short on substance. The idea that we do not know our siblings is obvious and is portrayed in many formats.
Most of the characters were poorly developed. The brother Michael came out of nowhere, and we never learned much about him. We learned almost nothing of the father until the revelations near the end. Whiskey could have been more fully developed by his mother, aunt, and wife.
Rating: 2
Would you recommend?: No --- just not enough there. Why spend time on this when there are so many books of real substance out in the world?
Would you read more by Smith?: No. I would read an unpublished manuscript to give an honest review.
Denise C. of Eldred, PA
A book telling about the life of twins. One gets hurt and the other tells about some life experiences. It was okay. Not really my type of book.
Rating: 2
Would you recommend?: No. It was boring.
Would you read more by Smith?: Probably not.
